DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift

$75.00



Go back in time with our Most Popular 90’s Mystery box! 💜 We theme and curate the box to your choices. This is our medium box. You can even select the color of your box, either a white, black or pink finish or you can be surprised!

If you are interested in a larger box than this one, go here: https://www.etsy.com/MagicUniqueTreasures/listing/1209000499

To see our Mini smaller box, click here: https://www.etsy.com/listing/1172566295

Each of our custom boxes are made right after you place your order, and your items are handpicked from our shop. The categories we carry are listed all the way below. For this size box, please limit category selections to 8-10 choices from our list, which works best for us to curate this box. Any more choices than 10 categories make boxes very difficult to theme, curate, personalize and bring together. Please try not to give us the category 90's horror, it's much too vague. To help us best personalize for you, please break down favorite horror characters or movies if possible.


Our Medium sized Mystery Boxes generally include:

One DVD featuring a 90's movie or show
One Disney Magazine
One 90's Book
One 90's Beanie Baby
One 90's toy
One Tamagotchi toy
One Sour Patch
Four pack of trading cards
Two Airheads
One slapwrist bracelet
Five buttons
Movie Stickers
and some more fun nostalgic surprises!

Here are some of the categories we have on hand and that we regularly have in stock & sell, and you can request to include any of these types of favorite items to customize & we can curate into your box:

98 Degrees
Addams Family
ALF
American Girl
Anastasia
Archie
Baby-Sitters Club
Backstreet Boys
Barbie
Batman
Beavis and Butthead
Beatles
Beanie Babies
Beetlejuice
Berenstain Bears
Beverly Cleary Books
Bob Marley
Boxcar Children
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Curious George
Despicable Me & Despicable Me 2
Dick Tracy
Dr. Seuss
Elvis
Fear Street
FernGully
Flintstones
Fleer Ultra Reboot
Friends (TV Show)
Friends Forever Books
Fright Flicks
Full House
Gilmore Girls
Girl Talk Books
GI Joe
Goosebumps
Harry Potter
Hello Kitty
Hot Wheels Cars
Indiana Jones
Judy Blume Books
Justin Bieber
Lil Miss Candy Stripes
Marilyn Monroe
Mary Kate & Ashley
My Little Pony
NSYNC
Nancy Drew
New Kids on the Block
Nickleodeon
Ninja Turtles
Peanuts
Point Horror (Christopher Pike, Caroline Cooney, etc)
Popeye
Power Rangers
Ricky Martin
Sabrina the Teenage Witch
Sailor Moon
Saved by the Bell
Scooby Doo
Shirley Temple
Simpsons
Smurfs
Spice Girls
Spider Man
Sponge Bob
Star Trek
Star Wars
Superman
Super Mario
Sweet Valley Kids, Twins, High, University, Seniors, etc.
VR Troopers
Will Smith
Wizard of Oz
X Files
90210


PLUS you can request for items anything and Everything Disney!

101 Dalmatians
Alice in Wonderland
Aladdin
Animal Kingdom
Beauty and the Beast
Cinderella
Donald Duck
Hercules
Hunchback of Notre Dame
Lion King
Little Mermaid
Mickey & Minnie
Mulan
Peter Pan
Pinocchio
Pocahontas
Rapunzel
Sleeping Beauty
Snow White
Three Caballeros
Toy Story
Winnie the Pooh

Shipping from United States

Processing time

3-5 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept cancellations

Legal imprint