Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Cart (
0
)
0
Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Contact us
Mystery Boxes
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$95.00
NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$95.00
Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts
$95.00
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan
$95.00
Y2K Mystery Box, MTV, Sailor Moon, Buffy, Fear Street, Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, 90's fan, 90s gift
$95.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift, Lisa Frank
$95.00
all Mystery Boxes
Buttons and Pins
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose One) 90s pins, 90s party favors
$2.75
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$2.75
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$13.75
Lisa Frank Buttons (1.25 inch) Choose One
$2.75
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons!
$2.75
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons!
$2.75
all Buttons and Pins
Book Collections
American Girl Collection - Choose One Book
$9.00
Boxcar Children- Choose a Title
$7.00
Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose Your Title
$8.00
Girl Talk Collection - Choose a Book by L.E. Blair
$10.00
Nancy Drew Files Series 1986-1993 Covers (Worn Condition)
$9.99
Hardy Boys Series -Choose a Title
$8.00
all Book Collections
Cartoon Collections
Archie Mystery Gift Pack
$14.99
Make Your Own Berenstain Bears Gift Bundle, Toy, Trading Cards, Coloring Book, Retro Gifts
$24.99
Berenstain Bears - One Sealed Trading Card Pack (1992)
$5.00
Popeye (1994) Trading Card Sealed Pack (6 Cards per Pack)
$4.99
Dick Tracy ONE Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 8 Cards) - 1990
$5.00
Woody Woodpecker (DVD + 1997 Collector Tin)
$19.99
all Cartoon Collections
Disney Collections
Disney Trading Card Pack (1992)
$6.00
Pocahontas Collections - Choose a Treasure
$4.00
TinkerBell Trading Card One Pack (SPANISH)
$8.00
Tarzan Collections - Choose a Treasure
$10.00
Birthday Card Sleeping Beauty with Sticker Pack (1998)
$10.00
Birthday Card Bambi with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992)
$10.00
all Disney Collections
Horror Collections
Chucky One Sealed Pack, Fright Rags
$20.00
Sister Dearest 1991 edition by D.E. Athkins
$14.99
Lois Duncan Thrillers (90's Covers) - Choose One
$12.99
1988 Fright Flicks - One Wax Pack (1988) Choose Your Pack
$9.99
The Watcher by Lael Littke 1994 1st Edition - Like NEW!
$34.99
Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books)
$9.99
all Horror Collections
Lisa Frank & Candies
Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers
$3.75
Lisa Frank Fun Pack
$16.00
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids
$5.00
Santa Around the World Trading Cards (1 Pack of 8 Cards), Stocking Stuffers, Family Traditions, Vintage Cards, Santa All Around the World
$4.00
Lisa Frank Premade 90's Party favors, 90s Birthday Favors, 90s Party, Lisa Frank Party
$25.00
Collectible Candy Tins filled with Candy! - Choose ONE
$24.99
all Lisa Frank & Candies
Movie Collections
Jim Carrey Collections - Choose a Treasure
$6.00
Dark Crystal & Labyrinth Collections - Choose a Treasure
$2.75
Free Willy 2 One Pack (1995)
$4.00
Indiana Jones Chronicles Trading Card Pack
$6.00
Addams Family One Pack (1991)
$5.00
FernGully Collections - Choose a Treasure
$5.00
all Movie Collections
Music Collections
Spice Girls Mini Treasure Packs, Gum Pack Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack) 1997
$5.00
New Kids on the Block Keychains
$3.50
Create your NKOTB Treat Bag, Gum Cassette, 90s Stocking Stuffer Nostalgic gift, 90's fan, Holiday Gift Ideas, New Kids on the Block
$19.99
New Kids on the Block Mystery Pack
$30.00
Backstreet Boys DUO Sets - Choose one 90's Photo/Trading Card Combo (90's Gifts, BSB, Boy Bands, 90's Throwback)
$2.00
Michael Jackson Collections, Choose a Treasure
$2.75
all Music Collections
Sports Collections
Football NFL Collections - Choose a Treasure
$15.00
Wrestling Collections - Choose a Treasure
$2.75
Baseball Stickers 1995 Edition One Pack
$3.00
all Sports Collections
Toy Collections
Beanie Baby (1998) Inaugural Edition Trading Cards - Choose One #1 to 54
$0.99
Chilly the Polar Bear Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack
$19.99
Teddy Beanie Baby Mystery Treasure Bag, 90s nostalgia, trading card, Valentine's day gift
$10.00
McDonalds Collectibles - Choose One
$5.00
Avon Robot Coin Piggy Bank Lost in Space (1985)
$24.99
Stretch the Ostrich Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards
$14.99
all Toy Collections
TV Show Collections
Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack
$12.00
Buffy Collections - Choose your Treasure
$12.00
August 1995 Power Rangers 90's Treasure Bag (90s magazine, Trading Cards, Disney Gift Idea)
$30.00
Sailor Moon Collections - Choose a Treasure
$2.75
Rugrats Trading Cards (1997) One Sealed Pack, Nickelodeon, Stocking Stuffers, Party Favors
$8.00
Saved by the Bell 1992 Single Cards - Choose Your Card (#64-110)
$2.99
all TV Show Collections
Babysitters Collections
Goodbye-Stacey, Good-bye #13 - Choose One Babysitters Club
$6.99
BSC#40-49 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Collectors Cover
$5.98
Jessi's Secret Language #16 - Choose One Babysitters Club
$3.99
Claudia and the New Girl #12- Choose One Babysitters Club
$3.99
Kristy's Great Idea #1 - Choose One Babysitters Club
$3.99
BSC Laminated Stoneybrook Map
$14.99
all Babysitters Collections
Fear Street/Pike/Cooney
Trick or Treat (1989 Cover) by Richie Tankersley Cusick
$16.99
Last Vampire Series - Choose One Christopher Pike Book
$9.99
Missing (UK 1994 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine
$24.99
Party Summer - Fear Street (1995) UK - Worn Copy
$39.00
Nightmare Room Collection - Choose One Book
$9.99
Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE
$35.00
all Fear Street/Pike/Cooney
Goosebumps Collections
Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy)
$10.00
Goosebumps Trading Cards (1 Pack) Choose Your Pack (Every pack comes with FREE GOOSEBUMPS STICKER)
$10.00
Let's Get Invisible! #6 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine
$9.99
Curse of the Mummy's Tomb #5 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine
$8.00
Say Cheese and Die! #4 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine
$8.00
Stay Out of the Basement #2 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine
$8.00
all Goosebumps Collections
Sweet Valley Collections
Sweet Valley Kids Super Specials - Choose ONE
$8.99
Sweet Valley High #21-29 - Choose a Cover
$5.99
Unicorn Club Series - Choose a Book by Francine Pascal
$10.00
Sweet Valley High Twin Sister Doll Fashions
$125.00
Sweet Valley Super Editions - Choose a Cover
$7.99
Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal
$15.00
all Sweet Valley Collections
Unique Card Collections
Huntik Trading Cards One Pack
$9.00
Iditarod Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards)
$5.00
Skeleton Warriors Premiere Edition Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 6 Cards)
$8.00
Desert Storm Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$4.00
Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$5.00
My Little Pony One (1986) Sticker Pack
$5.00
all Unique Card Collections
0 items in your cart
Close
Keep shopping! :)
Legal imprint
Close