Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Cart (
0
)
0
Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Contact us
MUT's Newest Treasures!
Disney Channel Millennial Mystery Box! High School Musical, Lizzie McGuire, Zac Efron, Mystery Box, Birthday Gifts, Goodie Box, 00's Box
$39.99
90's Mystery Box! Are You Afraid of the Dark? 90's Kids, Mystery Box, Birthday Gifts, Goodie Box, 90's Box
$59.99
Pirates of the Caribbean Trio Gift Set, Disney adventure magazine, Early 2000's, Birthday Gift Ideas
$
29.74
$34.99
December 1996, Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, 101 Dalmatians
$
16.99
$19.99
November 30th 1996, Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Toy Story
$
16.99
$19.99
October 1996, Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Mighty Ducks
$
16.99
$19.99
all MUT's Newest Treasures!
Mystery Box Treasures
Ultimate Britney Fan Mystery Box, Britney Spears, 90s box, 90s gift ideas, 90s gift box, Nostalgia, 90's Music
$
50.99
$59.99
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
59.49
$69.99
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
33.99
$39.99
Jurassic Park/World Birthday Gift Set, 90s gifts, Jurassic Park fan
$
16.99
$19.99
Buffy Mystery Treasure Box! Vintage gifts, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Idea
$
42.49
$49.99
Rugrats 90's Birthday Party Favors, Nostalgic gifts, Birthday bags, Retro 90s gift
$
6.79
$7.99
all Mystery Box Treasures
American Girl Treasures
Two Meet Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection
$
12.74
$14.99
Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection (Good Condition)
$
16.99
$19.99
Samantha Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition)
$
21.24
$24.99
Josefina Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition)
$
14.44
$16.99
Josefina Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition)
$
14.44
$16.99
Meet Felicity Hardcover 1st Edition w/ Dust Jacket and POSTCARD (Acceptable Condition)
$
16.99
$19.99
all American Girl Treasures
BabysittersClubTreasures
Stacey and the Stolen Hearts (1998 Edition)
$
21.25
$25.00
Little Sister #39 to 47 - Choose One Babysitters Club Book by Ann M. Martin
$
4.24
$4.99
Little Sister #30-38 - Choose One Book Babysitters Club Ann Martin
$
4.24
$4.99
Empty BSC BOOK Boxes! (Box ONLY)
$
11.04
$12.99
Little Sister 1-#20 - Choose One Book
$
3.39
$3.99
6 Book Set! (BSC Books 1 to 6) Babysitters Club First Six Books!
$
21.24
$24.99
all BabysittersClubTreasures
Buttons Treasures
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
0.85
$1.00
Mystery 5 Pack of 90s Pinback Buttons! Mystery Pack, 90s party, nostalgia gift, retro gift
$
4.25
$5.00
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
4.25
$5.00
Lisa Frank Set of Six (6) 90's Nostalgia 1.25 Inch Pinback Buttons
$
8.49
$9.99
90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
0.85
$1.00
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
4.25
$5.00
all Buttons Treasures
Disney Treasures
Lion King One Pack of 7 Pogs Slammers!
$
5.10
$6.00
Pocahontas Vintage Australian Happy Meal Box with Two 90's Trading Card Packs
$
6.80
$8.00
Mickey Mouse Care Package
$
29.74
$34.99
Walt Disney Burger King 1994 Collector Cups - Choose ONE
$
14.44
$16.99
Two Little Golden Books with Trading Cards
$
16.99
$19.99
Two Little Golden Books with Trading Cards
$
16.99
$19.99
all Disney Treasures
Fear Street Treasures
Choose One Fear Street Book (PART 2 of 2)
$
8.49
$9.99
Fear Street Cheerleaders: Choose One
$
12.74
$14.99
Point Horror Books: Choose ONE
$
8.50
$10.00
Wrong Number 1 & 2 Set (Worn Copies) 90's editions by RL Stine
$
21.25
$25.00
Stepsister & Stepsister 2 Set (1990/1995)
$
16.99
$19.99
The Fire Game (1991 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine
$
16.99
$19.99
all Fear Street Treasures
Goosebumps Treasures
Sticker Album Goosebumps (1996)
$
8.49
$9.99
Books#51 to 62 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book)
$
12.74
$14.99
1ST Editions # 31-40 - Choose One Goosebumps Book
$
8.49
$9.99
Goosebumps Postcard - Choose One
$
1.69
$1.99
Sticker Book PLUS 3 Packs Goosebumps Stickers (Merlin 1996)
$
29.74
$34.99
Goosebumps Trading Cards (1 Pack) Choose Your Pack (with FREE STICKER)
$
5.10
$6.00
all Goosebumps Treasures
Horror Treasures
Christopher Pike Assorted 90's Books: Choose One
$
8.49
$9.99
Spooky Trading Card Mix (5 Packs)
$
21.24
$24.99
Tales From the Crypt (1 pack) Trading Cards, 1993 packs
$
7.65
$9.00
Chucky (Fright Rags) One Sealed Pack
$
8.49
$9.99
Last Vampire Series - Choose One Christopher Pike Book
$
8.49
$9.99
Autographed Sweet Dreams by Kate Daniel (1992 1st Edition)
$
29.74
$34.99
all Horror Treasures
Movie/TV/Game Treasures
Grease - Random 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978)
$
5.09
$5.99
Mary Kate and Ashley in Action Bundle
$
12.74
$14.99
The Adventures of Mary Kate & Ashley Bundle
$
16.99
$19.99
The Adventures of Mary Kate & Ashley Bundle
$
21.24
$24.99
The Adventures of Mary Kate & Ashley Bundle
$
21.24
$24.99
The Adventures of Mary Kate & Ashley Bundle
$
14.44
$16.99
all Movie/TV/Game Treasures
Music Treasures
90's Music Trading Card Mix (5 Packs)
$
25.49
$29.99
Country Classics Trading Card Mix (5 Packs)
$
21.24
$24.99
Classics Trading Card Mix (5 Packs)
$
25.49
$29.99
90's Boy Bands Set (5 Packs)
$
16.99
$19.99
Backstreet Boys - One Sealed pack of 6 Photo Cards (1997)
$
2.55
$3.00
Backstreet Boys One Pack (10 cards) Trading Cards (2000)
$
3.39
$3.99
all Music Treasures
Nancy Drew Treasures
Nancy Drew (Flashlight Series) - Choose One Book
$
5.10
$6.00
Nancy Drew 1981 Gift Set (Fair Condition)
$
33.99
$39.99
Nancy Drew 1988 Gift Set 1 Books #1-5 (Fair Condition)
$
39.09
$45.99
Nancy Drew Diaries - Choose One!
$
8.50
$10.00
Nancy Drew Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
29.74
$34.99
Nancy Drew Notebooks - Hardcover (Former Library) - Choose ONE
$
8.49
$9.99
all Nancy Drew Treasures
New Kids on the Block
New Kids on the Block 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins
$
1.69
$1.99
NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
42.49
$49.99
NKOTB Mini Mystery Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts
$
21.24
$24.99
NKOTB Jordan Mini Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts
$
21.24
$24.99
NKOTB Mini MYSTERY Donnie Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts
$
21.24
$24.99
5 Keychain Pack of New Kids on The Block - with 1989 Trading Card Pack
$
8.49
$9.99
all New Kids on the Block
Sci Fi Treasures
Star Wars Bundle
$
12.74
$14.99
The X Files Card Mix (3 Packs)
$
14.44
$16.99
StarTrek Trading Card Mix (4 Packs and 1 Scratch Card)
$
16.99
$19.99
X Files Card Pack Series 2 by Topps (1996)
$
4.25
$5.00
X Files (Series 2) Trading Card Pack -1 Pack of 9 Cards 1996
$
3.39
$3.99
Star Trek Dark Victory 1st Edition 1999 Hardback Book w/ Jacket and Trading Cards
$
16.99
$19.99
all Sci Fi Treasures
Spice Girls Treasures
Spice Girls 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$49.99
Spice Girls Themed MYSTERY 90s Nostalgia Time Capsule
$19.99
Spice Girls Stickers - (3 Gum Pieces per Pack plus Movie Sticker) Nostalgic gift, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$6.00
Spice Girls Promo World Photographs (1997) - 1 Sealed Pack
$8.00
Spice Girls Photo & Sticker Sets - Choose one 90's Photo/Trading Card/Sticker Combo (90's Gifts, 90's Throwback, Girl Groups, Retro Gifts )
$5.00
1997 Spice Girls Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack)
$6.99
all Spice Girls Treasures
Sweet Valley Treasures
Sweet Valley Twins#31-40 (Classic Covers) - Choose One
$
8.07
$9.49
Sweet Valley Twins & Friends #1-10 - Choose One
$
5.10
$6.00
Lila's Secret Valentine (1995 Edition)
$
10.20
$12.00
Sweet Valley Kids #21-40 - Choose ONE Circle Cover
$
8.49
$9.99
Jessica Plays Cupid (1995 Edition)
$
11.04
$12.99
Elizabeth's Valentine (1990 1st Edition Purple Cover)
$
11.04
$12.99
all Sweet Valley Treasures
Trading Card Treasures
Barbie Little Golden Books (2 Books and 2 Cards)
$
12.74
$14.99
Rappin Rockin Barbie Mini Figure (1992)
$
8.49
$9.99
Rose Bride Barbie Figure (1992)
$
8.49
$9.99
90's Barbie Gift Set
$
16.99
$19.99
Barbie Themed 90s MYSTERY Nostalgia Time Capsule
$
14.44
$16.99
2 Packs Gremlins 2 Trading Cards with FREE Bonus Coloring Book! 80's Nostalgia gifts, retro gifts
$
16.99
$19.99
all Trading Card Treasures
Toy Treasures
Beanie Baby Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$
4.24
$4.99
GI Joe Time Capsule
$
29.74
$34.99
Teenie Beanie Baby Mystery Treasure Bag, 90s nostalgia, trading card,
$
5.95
$7.00
Bongo the Monkey Beanie Baby (1998) Sealed with Trading Cards
$
12.74
$14.99
Spangle the Bear Beanie Baby (2000 Retired) with Sealed Pack Trading Cards
$
42.49
$49.99
Millenium Bear Beanie Baby (2000 Retired) with Sealed Pack Trading Cards
$
42.49
$49.99
all Toy Treasures
Various Book Treasures
My Zombie Valentine (1993 Edition)
$
12.74
$14.99
Taffy Sinclair Goes to Hollywood (1990 1st Edition)
$
12.74
$14.99
Amazing Days of Abby Hayes Collection by Anne Mazer - Choose One
$
4.24
$4.99
2 Silver Blade Books 1994 & 1995 Cover (Rough/Worn Condition)
$
11.04
$12.99
Skating Dreams - Staying Balanced - Michelle Kwan Insert Still Intact Inside (Acceptable/Fair Copy)
$
21.24
$24.99
Skating Dreams - Champion's Luck - Michelle Kwan Insert Still Intact Inside (Good/Very Good Copy)
$
25.49
$29.99
all Various Book Treasures
0 items in your cart
Close
Keep shopping! :)
Legal imprint
Close
