Magic Unique Treasures

Magic Unique Treasures

Mystery Boxes

Totally 80s Trends Mystery Nostalgia Box! 80s Gifts, 80s Fans, Retro Boxes, Custom Totally 80s Trends Mystery Nostalgia Box! 80s Gifts, 80s Fans, Retro Boxes, Custom $95.00
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
DESIGN your 90's y2K Larger Size Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's y2K Larger Size Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $195.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
90's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift 90's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan 80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan $95.00
all Mystery Boxes

Babysitters Club

Babysitters Books #1 to 66 - Choose a Babysitters Club Book Babysitters Books #1 to 66 - Choose a Babysitters Club Book $8.00
Taffy Sinclair Goes to Hollywood (1990 1st Edition) Taffy Sinclair Goes to Hollywood (1990 1st Edition) $14.99
Display Babysitter's Club BOOK Boxes! No Books Display Babysitter's Club BOOK Boxes! No Books $15.00
Little Sister #61 to 122 - Choose a Book Little Sister #61 to 122 - Choose a Book $8.00
Baby-Sitters Club Trivia and Puzzle Fun Book (1992) Baby-Sitters Club Trivia and Puzzle Fun Book (1992) $24.99
Stoneybrook Family Photos - Babysitters Club (1991) Stoneybrook Family Photos - Babysitters Club (1991) $39.99
all Babysitters Club

Books

Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose Your Title Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose Your Title $8.00
Boxcar Children- Choose a Title Boxcar Children- Choose a Title $8.00
Who Knew? 25 Quizzes to Help You Find Your Secret Self (1999) - No Writing Who Knew? 25 Quizzes to Help You Find Your Secret Self (1999) - No Writing $19.99
Girl Talk Collection - Choose a Book by L.E. Blair Girl Talk Collection - Choose a Book by L.E. Blair $10.00
Nancy Drew Collections - Choose a Treasure Nancy Drew Collections - Choose a Treasure $3.00
Hardy Boys Series -Choose a Title Hardy Boys Series -Choose a Title $8.00
all Books

Buttons

Nickleodeon Six Pack 90's Style Buttons Nickleodeon Six Pack 90's Style Buttons $15.00
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $13.75
90s style (5 Pins) Pre-Made Combos 90s style (5 Pins) Pre-Made Combos $13.00
New Kids on the Block (Three Pack) 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins 1989 New Kids on the Block (Three Pack) 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins 1989 $9.75
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $2.75
90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 $2.75
all Buttons

Cartoons

Pokemon Mystery Goodie Bag, Nostalgia, Mystery bag, Stickers, Pikachu, 90's gifts, Holiday Gift Ideas Pokemon Mystery Goodie Bag, Nostalgia, Mystery bag, Stickers, Pikachu, 90's gifts, Holiday Gift Ideas $25.00
March 1994 Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Superman March 1994 Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Superman $19.99
September 30, 1995, Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Spiderman September 30, 1995, Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Spiderman $19.99
Pokemon VHS Sets, Pikachu Gifts, Vintage toys, Birthday Gift Ideas Pokemon VHS Sets, Pikachu Gifts, Vintage toys, Birthday Gift Ideas $24.99
Pokémon Tattoos (1995), One Sealed Pack, Button and Bonus Tattoo, Party Favors, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Ideas Pokémon Tattoos (1995), One Sealed Pack, Button and Bonus Tattoo, Party Favors, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Ideas $5.00
Super Mario Pez & Nintendo Stickers, 1992 Super Mario Pez & Nintendo Stickers, 1992 $15.00
all Cartoons

Disney

Hunchback Mystery Toy & Trading Cards, Gift Ideas, Retro Gifts, Toys, Disney, Hunchback of Notre Dame Hunchback Mystery Toy & Trading Cards, Gift Ideas, Retro Gifts, Toys, Disney, Hunchback of Notre Dame $14.99
Pocahontas Vintage Australian Happy Meal Box with Two 90's Trading Card Packs Pocahontas Vintage Australian Happy Meal Box with Two 90's Trading Card Packs $15.00
Simpsons Disney Magazine - February 1994 Simpsons Disney Magazine - February 1994 $30.00
Hercules Collections - Choose Your Treasure Hercules Collections - Choose Your Treasure $8.00
One Little Mermaid Sealed Trading Card Pack (1991) One Little Mermaid Sealed Trading Card Pack (1991) $6.00
Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) $6.00
all Disney

Fear Street/GOOSEBUMPS

Halloween Night Set (Worn Copies) by R.L. Stine Halloween Night Set (Worn Copies) by R.L. Stine $34.99
Goosebumps Spooky packs, 90's Books, Halloween gifts, Halloween, 90s gift ideas Goosebumps Spooky packs, 90's Books, Halloween gifts, Halloween, 90s gift ideas $29.99
Goosebumps Party Favors Goosebumps Party Favors $5.00
Fear Street/Point Horror (Red Dollar General Books ONLY) Fear Street/Point Horror (Red Dollar General Books ONLY) $12.00
Goosebumps TV Episode books, Original 90s Series R.L. Stine, Choose One Book Goosebumps TV Episode books, Original 90s Series R.L. Stine, Choose One Book $9.00
Goosebumps Books, Alternate Collector Covers, Choose One R.L. Stine book Goosebumps Books, Alternate Collector Covers, Choose One R.L. Stine book $8.00
all Fear Street/GOOSEBUMPS

Horror

Christopher Pike Books: Choose One Book Christopher Pike Books: Choose One Book $10.00
1988 Fright Flicks - One Wax Pack (1988) Choose Your Pack 1988 Fright Flicks - One Wax Pack (1988) Choose Your Pack $9.99
Caroline Cooney Books: Choose a Book Caroline Cooney Books: Choose a Book $8.00
Weird Eerie Indiana Collection - Choose a Book Weird Eerie Indiana Collection - Choose a Book $15.00
Barbara Steiner Collections - Choose a Book Barbara Steiner Collections - Choose a Book $10.00
A. Bates Collection - Choose a Book A. Bates Collection - Choose a Book $10.00
all Horror

Lisa Frank & More

Lisa Frank Fun Pack Lisa Frank Fun Pack $16.00
Lisa Frank Buttons (1.25 inch) Choose One Lisa Frank Buttons (1.25 inch) Choose One $2.75
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids $5.95
Lisa Frank Premade 90's Party favors, 90s Birthday Favors, 90s Party, Lisa Frank Party Lisa Frank Premade 90's Party favors, 90s Birthday Favors, 90s Party, Lisa Frank Party $25.00
TY Beanie Babies 1999 Sealed, Choose ONE, International, Erin Britannia Glory Maple, Stocking Stuffers, 90's Gifts TY Beanie Babies 1999 Sealed, Choose ONE, International, Erin Britannia Glory Maple, Stocking Stuffers, 90's Gifts $15.00
Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers $3.95
all Lisa Frank & More

Movies

90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $13.75
Flintstones Pack (Barney & Betty) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) Flintstones Pack (Barney & Betty) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) $3.00
Bill & Ted's Collections - Choose a Treasure Bill & Ted's Collections - Choose a Treasure $6.00
Flintstones Pack (Fred & Wilma) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) Flintstones Pack (Fred & Wilma) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) $3.00
Charlie & the Chocolate Factory Mini Movie Card Pack Charlie & the Chocolate Factory Mini Movie Card Pack $2.00
Grease Surprise 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978) Grease Surprise 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978) $5.99
all Movies

Music

90s style *NSYNC Sticker and 3 Pinback buttons, 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons, *NSYNC 90s style *NSYNC Sticker and 3 Pinback buttons, 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons, *NSYNC $9.75
Spice Girls (3 pieces) Gum with Bonus Sticker Spice Girls (3 pieces) Gum with Bonus Sticker $5.00
NSYNC Surprise Pack (6 photos) 1999 NSYNC Surprise Pack (6 photos) 1999 $6.00
Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) $30.00
98 Degrees Photo Pack (One Pack) 98 Degrees Photo Pack (One Pack) $10.00
Bob Marley Gift Set, CD, Trading Cards 1995 Bob Marley Gift Set, CD, Trading Cards 1995 $20.00
all Music

Sports

Wrestling Collections - Choose a Treasure Wrestling Collections - Choose a Treasure $2.75
Baseball Stickers 1995 Edition One Pack Baseball Stickers 1995 Edition One Pack $3.00
Football Collection - Choose a Treasure Football Collection - Choose a Treasure $15.00
all Sports

Sweet Valley

Sweet Valley Jr. High Collection - Choose One Book by Francine Pascal Sweet Valley Jr. High Collection - Choose One Book by Francine Pascal $10.00
Sweet Valley High #11 to 70 - Choose a Book Sweet Valley High #11 to 70 - Choose a Book $10.00
Sweet Valley Confidential - Choose One by Francine Pascal Sweet Valley Confidential - Choose One by Francine Pascal $10.00
Sweet Valley High #1-10 - Choose a Book Sweet Valley High #1-10 - Choose a Book $10.00
Sweet Valley (#31-60) Twins Books- Choose a Book Sweet Valley (#31-60) Twins Books- Choose a Book $6.00
Secret Love Diaries Collection - Choose a Sweet Valley Book Secret Love Diaries Collection - Choose a Sweet Valley Book $10.00
all Sweet Valley

TV Shows

1x Sealed (2000) Sailor Moon Deck 1x Sealed (2000) Sailor Moon Deck $29.99
Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack $12.00
Sabrina Collections - Choose a Treasure Sabrina the Teenage Witch Show Sabrina Collections - Choose a Treasure Sabrina the Teenage Witch Show $2.75
Two of a Kind - Choose One Mary Kate & Ashley Book (1999) Two of a Kind - Choose One Mary Kate & Ashley Book (1999) $8.00
Choose One Star Trek SkyBox (1994) Choose One Star Trek SkyBox (1994) $19.99
Sailor Moon - Choose a Treasure Sailor Moon - Choose a Treasure $2.75
all TV Shows

Unique Finds

Leaf Printer - Happy Meal Toy 1993 Leaf Printer - Happy Meal Toy 1993 $8.00
Americana Historic Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) Americana Historic Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) $4.00
Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $5.00
Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) $9.99
Jeffrey Jones Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Jeffrey Jones Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $5.00
Marilyn Monroe (1 Pack of 9 Cards) - 1995 Marilyn Monroe (1 Pack of 9 Cards) - 1995 $6.00
all Unique Finds

Legal imprint