Magic Unique Treasures

Magic Unique Treasures

MUT's Newest Treasures!

Power Rangers (1994) Trading Cards (One Sealed Pack) Power Rangers (1994) Trading Cards (One Sealed Pack) $4.99
Backstreet Boys Group Base Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter Backstreet Boys Group Base Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter $1.00
Backstreet Boys Trading Cards (2000) Choose your 5 Cards, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter Backstreet Boys Trading Cards (2000) Choose your 5 Cards, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter $5.00
Backstreet Boys Group Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter Backstreet Boys Group Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter $1.25
Backstreet Boys Album Rookie Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter Backstreet Boys Album Rookie Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter $24.99
Backstreet Boys Album Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter Backstreet Boys Album Trading Card Collection (2000) Choose 1 Card, BSB, Trading Cards, Nick Carter $2.00
all MUT's Newest Treasures!

80s Button Treasures

Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $1.00
all 80s Button Treasures

90s Buttons Treasures

90s style 5 Pinback buttons (Choose your OWN Random Mix of 5) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style 5 Pinback buttons (Choose your OWN Random Mix of 5) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $5.00
Mystery 5 Pack of 90s Pinback Buttons! Mystery Pack, 90s party, nostalgia gift, retro gift Mystery 5 Pack of 90s Pinback Buttons! Mystery Pack, 90s party, nostalgia gift, retro gift $5.00
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $1.99
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $1.00
Choose (One) 90's Nostalgia 1.25 Inch Pinback Buttons, 90s gifts, Trading Cards Choose (One) 90's Nostalgia 1.25 Inch Pinback Buttons, 90s gifts, Trading Cards $1.99
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $1.00
all 90s Buttons Treasures

90s & 80s Box Treasures

DESIGN your 90's Larger Size Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Larger Size Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $89.99
90's Mini Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift 90's Mini Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $19.99
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $69.99
90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $59.99
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $69.99
90's Blue Blast Mystery Box! 90's Kids, Mystery Box, Birthday Gifts, Goodie Box, Blue Blast Box 90's Blue Blast Mystery Box! 90's Kids, Mystery Box, Birthday Gifts, Goodie Box, Blue Blast Box $59.99
all 90s & 80s Box Treasures

Goodie Bag Treasures

Very Cherry Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Cherry Flavors) Very Cherry Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Cherry Flavors) $3.50
Scooby Doo Mystery Bundle (Gift Idea, Nostalgic Gift) Scooby Doo Mystery Bundle (Gift Idea, Nostalgic Gift) $15.00
Sailor Moon Trading Card Treat Bag Sailor Moon Trading Card Treat Bag $8.00
Fruit Chews Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Fruit Chew Flavors) Fruit Chews Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Fruit Chew Flavors) $4.50
Water Magical Melon Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Watermelon Flavors) Water Magical Melon Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Watermelon Flavors) $3.50
Blue Razzle Dazzle Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Blue Raspberry Flavors) Blue Razzle Dazzle Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Blue Raspberry Flavors) $4.50
all Goodie Bag Treasures

Disney Treasures

1994 Disney Packs, Choose One Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Packs 1994 Disney Packs, Choose One Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Packs $19.99
Toy Story Gift Set (DVD + 2 Sealed 1995 Packs + Disney 1996 Magazine) Toy Story Gift Set (DVD + 2 Sealed 1995 Packs + Disney 1996 Magazine) $24.99
Design Your Own (Disney Mini Treat Bag) Design Your Own (Disney Mini Treat Bag) $3.00
Little Mermaid 90's Set - 1996 Gold Sebastian Wind-up Toy & 1991 Trading Cards Little Mermaid 90's Set - 1996 Gold Sebastian Wind-up Toy & 1991 Trading Cards $12.99
One Vintage Pack Donald Duck (6 Stickers inside) One Vintage Pack Donald Duck (6 Stickers inside) $3.99
Donald & Daisy Gift Treat Bag (1990's stickers and toys) Donald & Daisy Gift Treat Bag (1990's stickers and toys) $19.99
all Disney Treasures

Horror Treasures

Nightmare Room Collection - Choose One Book Nightmare Room Collection - Choose One Book $9.99
1988 Fright Flicks - Pumpkinhead Pack 1988 Fright Flicks - Pumpkinhead Pack $9.99
1988 Fright Flicks - Predator Pack (1988) 1988 Fright Flicks - Predator Pack (1988) $9.99
1988 Fright Flicks - Fright Night Pack 1988 Fright Flicks - Fright Night Pack $9.99
Casper (1995 First Edition) Good Condition Casper (1995 First Edition) Good Condition $9.99
Carol Ellis Books - Choose One Carol Ellis Books - Choose One $9.99
all Horror Treasures

Music Treasures

Spice Girls 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift Spice Girls 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $59.99
Country's Classics Box Series 1 Trading Card Collection (100 Card Base SET) 1992 Country's Classics Box Series 1 Trading Card Collection (100 Card Base SET) 1992 $9.99
Scary Spice 90's Spice Girls Care Package Scary Spice 90's Spice Girls Care Package $39.99
1997 Spice Girls Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack) 1997 Spice Girls Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack) $3.00
Backstreet Boys - One Sealed pack of 6 Photo Cards (1997) Backstreet Boys - One Sealed pack of 6 Photo Cards (1997) $3.00
NSYNC 1 Sealed Pack (6 photos) 1999 NSYNC 1 Sealed Pack (6 photos) 1999 $4.00
all Music Treasures

Sci Fi Treasures

Point Horror (FRENCH) RL Stine - Choose ONE Book (1991-94) Point Horror (FRENCH) RL Stine - Choose ONE Book (1991-94) $16.99
Star Wars Treasures Star Wars Treasures $29.99
Star Wars Treasures Star Wars Treasures $29.99
Star Wars Treasures Star Wars Treasures $29.99
Star Wars Treasures Star Wars Treasures $29.99
Star Wars Treasures Star Wars Treasures $29.99
all Sci Fi Treasures

Toy Treasures

My Little Pony Gift Set (DVD + Lunch Box + 2 Ponies + Glasses & Headband) My Little Pony Gift Set (DVD + Lunch Box + 2 Ponies + Glasses & Headband) $19.99
Woody Woodpecker (DVD + 1997 Collector Tin) Woody Woodpecker (DVD + 1997 Collector Tin) $19.99
Flintstones Barney Gift Set (1992 & 1993) Flintstones Barney Gift Set (1992 & 1993) $12.99
Avon Robot Coin Piggy Bank Lost in Space (1985) Avon Robot Coin Piggy Bank Lost in Space (1985) $24.99
1997 Super Nintendo 64 N64 Mario Kart Controller Handheld Maze Game Toy 1997 Super Nintendo 64 N64 Mario Kart Controller Handheld Maze Game Toy $19.99
Super Mario Ball (1997) Cube Maze Nintendo N64 Game (8 sides Character) Super Mario Ball (1997) Cube Maze Nintendo N64 Game (8 sides Character) $29.99
all Toy Treasures

Trading Card Treasures

Buffy Ultra-Premium Trading Card Sealed Pack (2003) Buffy Ultra-Premium Trading Card Sealed Pack (2003) $4.99
90210 (1991) Trading Card Sealed Pack (8 Cards per Pack) 90210 (1991) Trading Card Sealed Pack (8 Cards per Pack) $5.00
Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack $8.00
1 Bag of Empty 90's Trading Card Wrappers (Arts + Crafts) 1 Bag of Empty 90's Trading Card Wrappers (Arts + Crafts) $5.00
American Pride Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 5 Cards) American Pride Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 5 Cards) $2.50
William Stout Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) William Stout Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $4.99
all Trading Card Treasures

Various Book Treasures

Goddess Girls - Pallas the Pal by Holub & Williams Goddess Girls - Pallas the Pal by Holub & Williams $5.99
Full House: Stephanie Collection - Choose One Book Full House: Stephanie Collection - Choose One Book $6.00
Stage Fright (Blue Cover) By Ann M. Martin - Gently Used Paperback Stage Fright (Blue Cover) By Ann M. Martin - Gently Used Paperback $9.99
Pen Pals Collection: Choose One Book Pen Pals Collection: Choose One Book $5.90
Sleepover Friends Collection: Choose One Book Sleepover Friends Collection: Choose One Book $2.50
Boxcar Children (1989 Cover) #2 Surprise Island (Acceptable/Fair Copy) Boxcar Children (1989 Cover) #2 Surprise Island (Acceptable/Fair Copy) $14.99
all Various Book Treasures

American Girl Treasures

American Girl Mystery Gift Set (Magazine + 2 Books + 2 Postcards) American Girl Mystery Gift Set (Magazine + 2 Books + 2 Postcards) $24.99
American Girl - Choose One American Girl - Choose One $5.00
Two Meet Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection Two Meet Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection $14.99
Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection (Good Condition) Kit Books with Promo Ad! American Girl Collection (Good Condition) $19.99
Samantha Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition) Samantha Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition) $24.99
Josefina Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition) Josefina Books (Before & After) with Promo Ad from 1997 (Acceptable Condition) $16.99
all American Girl Treasures

BabysittersClubTreasures

BSC #80-99 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Collectors Cover BSC #80-99 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Collectors Cover $9.98
The Truth About Stacey #3 - Choose One Babysitters Club The Truth About Stacey #3 - Choose One Babysitters Club $3.99
BSC Portrait Collection - Choose ONE Babysitter's Club Book BSC Portrait Collection - Choose ONE Babysitter's Club Book $5.00
Super Mysteries 1-4 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Book Super Mysteries 1-4 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Book $9.99
BSC Claudia Hand Crafted Framed Collage (9.5x11.5) BSC Claudia Hand Crafted Framed Collage (9.5x11.5) $34.99
Babysitters Club RARE Scholastic 90's Poster! Babysitters Club RARE Scholastic 90's Poster! $85.00
all BabysittersClubTreasures

Beanie Baby Treasures

Power Rangers 90's Treasure Bag (90s magazine, Trading Cards, Disney Gift Idea) Power Rangers 90's Treasure Bag (90s magazine, Trading Cards, Disney Gift Idea) $24.99
Claude the Crab Beanie Baby (1993) with Sealed Trading Card Pack Claude the Crab Beanie Baby (1993) with Sealed Trading Card Pack $9.99
Dinky the Bird Beanie Baby (2000 Edition) with Sealed Trading Card Pack Dinky the Bird Beanie Baby (2000 Edition) with Sealed Trading Card Pack $16.99
USA Bear Beanie Baby (2000 Edition) with Sealed Trading Card Pack USA Bear Beanie Baby (2000 Edition) with Sealed Trading Card Pack $29.99
Ariel Bear Beanie Baby (2000) with Sealed Trading Card Pack Ariel Bear Beanie Baby (2000) with Sealed Trading Card Pack $29.99
Neon the Seahorse Teenie Beanie Baby (1999) with Sealed Trading Card Pack Neon the Seahorse Teenie Beanie Baby (1999) with Sealed Trading Card Pack $19.99
all Beanie Baby Treasures

Fear Street Treasures

Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE $35.00
Fear Street Super Chillers by RL Stine - Choose ONE Book Fear Street Super Chillers by RL Stine - Choose ONE Book $9.99
Lights Out (1991 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine Lights Out (1991 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine $24.99
Fear Hall The Beginning & Conclusion (1997) Covers - Choose One Fear Hall The Beginning & Conclusion (1997) Covers - Choose One $16.99
The Snowman (Choose Your Cover) The Snowman (Choose Your Cover) $9.00
Creepy Collection #3 Ghosts of Fear Street by R.L. Stine Creepy Collection #3 Ghosts of Fear Street by R.L. Stine $19.99
all Fear Street Treasures

Goosebumps Treasures

Goosebumps 90's Mystery Pack , Nostalgic gifts, Slappy, Goosebumps books, YA books Goosebumps 90's Mystery Pack , Nostalgic gifts, Slappy, Goosebumps books, YA books $24.99
1ST Editions #41-50 - Choose One Goosebumps Book 1ST Editions #41-50 - Choose One Goosebumps Book $9.99
Books#51 to 62 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) Books#51 to 62 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) $14.99
Books# 1 to 10 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) Books# 1 to 10 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) $6.99
Books# 31 to 40 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) Books# 31 to 40 (Choose One 90's Goosebumps Book) $6.00
Goosebumps Books! Choose One Variant Cover Goosebumps Books! Choose One Variant Cover $5.00
all Goosebumps Treasures

Nancy Drew Treasures

Nancy Drew Books - Choose One Nancy Drew Books - Choose One $10.00
Nancy Drew Two in One Book (1997) Books #1 & 2 Nancy Drew Two in One Book (1997) Books #1 & 2 $6.99
Hardy Boys (Flashlight Series) - Choose One Book Hardy Boys (Flashlight Series) - Choose One Book $8.00
Nancy Drew (Flashlight Series) - Choose One Book Nancy Drew (Flashlight Series) - Choose One Book $6.00
Nancy Drew 1981 Gift Set (Fair Condition) Nancy Drew 1981 Gift Set (Fair Condition) $39.99
Nancy Drew 1988 Gift Set 1 Books #1-5 (Fair Condition) Nancy Drew 1988 Gift Set 1 Books #1-5 (Fair Condition) $45.99
all Nancy Drew Treasures

New Kids on the Block

New Kids on the Block 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins Choose One New Kids on the Block 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins Choose One $1.99
NKOTB (Nostalgia Gift Set) Comic Book Sealed 1991 Issue NKOTB (Nostalgia Gift Set) Comic Book Sealed 1991 Issue $20.00
Choose ONE New Kids on The Block Keychain Choose ONE New Kids on The Block Keychain $1.99
New Kids on The Block Surprise Bag, Retro 90s gift, nostalgia New Kids on The Block Surprise Bag, Retro 90s gift, nostalgia $6.00
NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $59.99
New Kids on the Block Choose One 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins New Kids on the Block Choose One 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins $1.99
all New Kids on the Block

Sweet Valley Treasures

Secret Diaries Sweet Valley High - Choose ONE Secret Diaries Sweet Valley High - Choose ONE $9.99
Sweet Valley High #41-50 - Choose One Sweet Valley High #41-50 - Choose One $5.99
Sweet Valley High #21-29 - Choose a Cover Sweet Valley High #21-29 - Choose a Cover $5.99
Sweet Valley High #91-100 - Choose One Sweet Valley High #91-100 - Choose One $9.99
Sweet Valley High #11-20 - Choose a Cover Sweet Valley High #11-20 - Choose a Cover $5.99
SVU: #21-30 - Choose ONE Sweet Valley University Book SVU: #21-30 - Choose ONE Sweet Valley University Book $6.00
all Sweet Valley Treasures

Legal imprint