Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Cart (
0
)
0
Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Contact us
**MYSTERY BOXES**
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan
$
71.25
$95.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
71.25
$95.00
Time Capsule Mystery Box - Choose Your Year
$
97.49
$129.99
80s/90s Trends REMIX Mystery Box
$
71.25
$95.00
LARGE 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$
146.25
$195.00
Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts
$
71.25
$95.00
all **MYSTERY BOXES**
BEANIE BABIES
Beanie of the Day (October 30th) Radar the Bat, Beanie Baby Birthday Telegram Treat, Stocking Stuffers, 90s gifts
$
3.75
$5.00
Teenie Beanie Baby Mystery Treasure Bag, 90s nostalgia, trading card,
$
10.69
$14.25
Beanie of the Day (October 11th) Speedy the Turtle, Floppity, Beanie Baby Birthday Telegram Treat, Stocking Stuffers, 90s gifts
$
7.49
$9.99
Cocker Spaniel Spunky Teenie Beanie Baby with Trading Card Gift Set
$
7.49
$9.99
Beanie Baby Series 4 Checklist Trading Card
$
1.69
$2.25
Beanie of the Day (October 31st) Spooky the Ghost), Beanie Baby Birthday Telegram Treat, Stocking Stuffers, 90s gifts
$
3.75
$5.00
all BEANIE BABIES
BOOKS
Mary Kate & Ashley Adventures and New Adventures - Choose a Book
$
9.71
$12.95
Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose a Title BY Carolyn Keene
$
11.24
$14.99
Hardy Boys - Pick a Book
$
6.00
$8.00
Tom Sawyer 5 Audio Cassette Box Set (Sealed) 1995, Books on Cassette
$
18.75
$25.00
Three Books in One Nancy Drew Hardcover Book
$
14.99
$19.99
BSC Laminated Stoneybrook Map
$
14.99
$19.99
all BOOKS
BUTTONS
Mystery Scoop of 90's themed Buttons, Party Favors
$
11.24
$14.99
80s Party Buttons 1.25 inch - Pick Buttons
$
2.24
$2.99
80s style Pinback buttons, Choose, 80s Party Favors
$
2.24
$2.99
80s style Pinback buttons, Choose Buttons, 80s Party, 80s Party Favors, 80s Button
$
2.24
$2.99
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
2.06
$2.75
90s themes Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$
2.06
$2.75
all BUTTONS
DIGITAL DOWNLOADS
Year 2000 Fun Fact | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | y2k Party | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations |
$
1.49
$1.99
Year 1973 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 50th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations |
$
1.49
$1.99
Babysitters Club Original Series 1-131 Book List | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | PRINTABLE | Reading Tracker
$
2.99
$3.99
Year 1999 Fun Fact | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | 90s Party | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations |
$
1.49
$1.99
Year 1993 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 30th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations |
$
1.49
$1.99
Year 1983 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 40th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations |
$
1.49
$1.99
all DIGITAL DOWNLOADS
DISNEY
Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad, Headless Horseman 2003 Disney Treasures Trading Card
$
4.49
$5.99
Toy Story 1996 Disney Adventures Magazine
$
18.71
$24.95
Birthday Card Cinderella with Trading Card Pack (1995)
$
11.25
$15.00
Koda Brother Bear 2003 Disney Treasures Trading Card
$
4.49
$5.99
Gargoyles 1994 Disney Adventures Magazine
$
29.96
$39.95
Power Rangers Disney Magazine, 1994, 90s Kids, 90s Party, 90s Gift Ideas, Nostalgia
$
22.46
$29.95
all DISNEY
FEAR STREET
Fear Park Series - Choose a Fear Street Book
$
15.00
$20.00
Fear Street Hardcovers Ex-Library Editions - Choose Yours
$
18.75
$25.00
Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE
$
26.25
$35.00
Silent Night Collection - Choose a Fear Street Book
$
14.96
$19.95
Fear Street Hand Crafted Collage (9.5x11.5) INCLUDES FRAME
$
44.99
$59.99
Fear Street (Simon Pulse Editions) - Choose a Book
$
12.71
$16.95
all FEAR STREET
GIFT IDEAS
Disney Collector Burger King Cups 1994 - Choose ONE
$
22.49
$29.99
Archie Mystery Gift Pack
$
18.74
$24.99
Super Mario Pez & Nintendo Stickers, 1992
$
11.25
$15.00
Kristy and the Triple Trouble - Mini BSC Collector's Book (Not an Actual Book 1993)
$
18.74
$24.99
Claudia Saves the Day - Mini BSC Collector's Book (Not an Actual Book 1993)
$
18.74
$24.99
Mallory and the Pet Disaster! Mini BSC Collector Book (Not an Actual Book 1993)
$
18.74
$24.99
all GIFT IDEAS
GOOSEBUMPS
GOOSEBUMPS Apple Paperbacks, You Choose the Scare! R.L Stine's Retro Books, Kids Horror, Throwback, 90s
$
14.99
$19.99
TALES to Give You GOOSEBUMPS Paperbacks You Choose the Scare! R.L Stine's Retro Books, Kids Horror, Throwback, 90s
$
14.99
$19.99
Goosebumps Two Movie Novel Paperbacks
$
14.96
$19.95
RL Stine (Young at Heart) 1996 Hard Cover (Acceptable Condition)
$
13.50
$18.00
GOOSEBUMPS Ghosts of Fear Street Paperbacks, You Choose the Scare! R.L Stine's Retro Books, Kids Horror, Throwback, 90s
$
7.46
$9.95
Goosebumps Cards - Choose a Collector Card
$
5.99
$7.99
all GOOSEBUMPS
HALLOWEEN
Beetlejuice One Pack (1990)
$
5.96
$7.95
Sweet Valley Kids Halloween Titles - Choose a Book by Francine Pascal
$
7.46
$9.95
90s Style Buttons, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, Scream
$
2.06
$2.75
Casper Collections - Choose a Treasure
$
2.06
$2.75
Addams Family One Pack (1991)
$
3.75
$5.00
Hocus Pocus Vinyl Sticker & Button, Halloween stickers, Halloween gifts, 90's Movies
$
2.06
$2.75
all HALLOWEEN
HORROR
Christopher Pike Collection, Choose a Paperback Book
$
7.50
$10.00
Nightmare Room - Choose One R.L. Stine Book (2001)
$
7.50
$10.00
Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose a Book
$
11.25
$15.00
Carol Ellis Books - Choose a Title
$
11.21
$14.95
Bruce Coville Collection - Choose a Book
$
9.00
$12.00
Mystery Pack (Tales from The Crypt Book & Trading Card Pack) 1993
$
18.74
$24.99
all HORROR
MUSIC
Spice Girls Autograph Book with Pen (Sealed) 1997
$
44.96
$59.95
Choose a Spice Girls Sticker From 1997 collection, Ginger Spice, Baby Spice, Sporty Spice, Posh Spice, Scary Spice. NO GUM
$
2.99
$3.99
Rock Cards (One 1991 Trading Card Pack) Each Pack has 13 Cards Inside, Motley Crue, Anthrax, Bon Jovi
$
4.49
$5.99
Country's Classics One Box Series 1 Trading Card Collection (100 Card Base SET) 1992
$
14.99
$19.99
NSYNC Magnets - Choose A MAGNET (2.75 by 3.75 inches)
$
14.99
$19.99
NSYNC Gold, Choose One CARD, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake
$
7.49
$9.99
all MUSIC
NICKELODEON
Rugrats Japan Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue
$
29.96
$39.95
Rugrats Thailand Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue
$
29.96
$39.95
Rugrats Italy Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue
$
29.96
$39.95
Rugrats Canada Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia
$
29.96
$39.95
Rugrats Russia Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia
$
29.96
$39.95
Rugrats Kenya Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue
$
29.96
$39.95
all NICKELODEON
NKOTB New Kids BLOCK
NKOTB Mini Mystery Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts
$
22.46
$29.95
New Kids on the Block (Three Pack) 1.5 Inch Pin-back Buttons, NKOTB Fan Gift, NKOTB Buttons, New Old Stock Vintage Pins 1989
$
11.21
$14.95
New Kids on the Block Stickers - Pick Your (1989 Sticker)
$
1.69
$2.25
NKOTB (Nostalgia Gift Set) Comic Book 1991 Issue
$
29.99
$39.99
NKOTB (Nostalgia Gift Set) Comic Book 1991 Issue
$
29.99
$39.99
NKOTB (Nostalgia Gift Set) Comic Book 1991 Issue
$
29.99
$39.99
all NKOTB New Kids BLOCK
SWEET VALLEY
Sweet Valley Twins Super Chillers - Choose a Book by Francine Pascal
$
11.21
$14.95
SWEET VALLEY #1-49 TWINS & Friends 1998 editions, Choose a Title by Francine Pascal, Build your own Book Lot
$
11.21
$14.95
Sweet Valley High books with Color Spine Paperback, Choose a book
$
11.21
$14.95
Sweet Valley Kids, Super Specials Choose a book below by Francine Pascal
$
7.46
$9.95
Sweet Valley High #1-10 - Choose a Book
$
11.21
$14.95
Evil Twins - Choose ONE Sweet Valley High Book
$
22.46
$29.95
all SWEET VALLEY
TEEN MAGAZINES
Sabrina 2002 Magazine, Summer Special, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
44.96
$59.95
Sabrina 2002 Magazine, Issue 63, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
29.96
$39.95
Sabrina 2002 Magazine, Issue 38, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
29.96
$39.95
Sabrina 2002 Magazine, Issue 64, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
29.96
$39.95
Sabrina 2002 Magazine, Issue 54, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
29.96
$39.95
Sabrina Magazine, Issue 36, Sabrina Secrets, Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV Show, Nickleodeon, TGIF
$
29.96
$39.95
all TEEN MAGAZINES
TOYS
Barbie & Friends 1994 Toy Collection - Choose a Toy, Gift, (Cake Topper Idea)
$
11.21
$14.95
Dragon Ball Z Burger King Kids Meal Toys - Pick One
$
7.50
$10.00
Millennium Princess Barbie (sealed toy) 1999 Mattel
$
12.71
$16.95
Sparkle Eyes Barbie with 1990 Barbie Fashion Card, (Cake Topper, Birthday Gift)
$
12.71
$16.95
Sun Barbie with 1988 Barbie Fashion Card
$
9.71
$12.95
American Girl Toy Books, Stocking Stuffers, Choose, Gift Ideas, American Girl, 90s Inspired, Birthday Gifts
$
14.99
$19.99
all TOYS
TRADING CARDS
TGIF Laffs Trading Cards (One Sealed 1991 Pack)
$
5.06
$6.75
Blueprints of the Future Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$
3.74
$4.99
Bingo Movie Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$
2.24
$2.99
Princess Diana Collections - Choose One, Magazine, Book or Trading Card Pack, Princess of Wales, King Charles, Prince William, Prince Harry
$
2.06
$2.75
Dinosaurs Attack One Pack (1988)
$
3.75
$5.00
Nintendo Sticker Pack (6 Stickers) 1992
$
7.49
$9.99
all TRADING CARDS
TV GUIDES
Simpsons Show (Apu) Collector Gift Set Magazine/Toy
$
18.74
$24.99
TV Guide 1990 Preowned, Challenger, Brady Bunch, Perfect Strangers, Sean Connery, Nostalgia Full House, Nostalgia
$
11.21
$14.95
Madonna Gift Set (TV Guide/CD)
$
18.74
$24.99
Janet Jackson Collector Set - TV Guide, CD, Trading Cards
$
29.99
$39.99
TV Guide 1998 Preowned, Matthew Perry, Friends, 90s TV Nostalgia
$
14.96
$19.95
TV Guide 1993 Preowned, Joey Lawrence, Blossom, 90s TV Nostalgia
$
14.96
$19.95
all TV GUIDES
TV SHOW & MOVIES
John Candy 1991 Disney Adventures Magazine
$
22.46
$29.95
Buffy Sealed Trading Pack, Buffy the Vampire Slayer
$
7.49
$9.99
Angel Playing Card Collector's Deck 2003 Sealed Pack
$
14.99
$19.99
Saved by the Bell 1992 Single Cards - Choose Your Card (#64-110)
$
2.96
$3.95
The Mask One Trading Pack 1994 - Factory Sealed
$
11.24
$14.99
Sabrina Binder with TWO sealed Packs, Sabrina the Teenage Witch, 90's Gifts
$
44.96
$59.95
all TV SHOW & MOVIES
0 items in your cart
Close
Keep shopping! :)
Legal imprint
Close
