Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Cart (
0
)
0
Magic Unique Treasures
Shop
Events
Gallery
Contact us
Mystery Boxes
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan
$95.00
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$85.00
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$85.00
DESIGN your MINI 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$65.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift
$85.00
NSYNC Care Package, Mystery Box, *NSYNC, Pop Music 90s box, 90s gift ideas, 90s gift box, Nostalgia, Justin Timberlake
$95.00
all Mystery Boxes
Back to the 80's
Dark Crystal 1982 Single Trading Cards - Choose ONE
$2.00
E.T. Button & Mystery Card, 80s Party favors, Gift ideas, 80s pins
$2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons!
$2.00
80s Style Buttons, 80s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 80s gift ideas, 80s pins, Ninja Turtles
$2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons!
$2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons!
$2.00
all Back to the 80's
Back to the 60's & 70's
Grease Surprise 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978)
$5.99
Two Little Golden Books with Trading Cards
$19.99
Beatles Treat Bag Covers Vary (One 1993 Trading Card Pack Inside)
$9.99
Bob Marley One 1995 Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 6 Cards)
$5.00
Beatles - One Trading Card Pack of 9 Cards (1996)
$7.99
Bob Marley Gift Set, CD, Trading Cards 1995
$20.00
all Back to the 60's & 70's
Babysitters Collections
Little Sister Book #66-74 - Choose One Babysitters Club Book By Ann M. Martin
$6.99
3 Book Set! (BSC Books 4 to 6) Babysitters Club
$10.00
Baby-Sitters Club Halloween Mysteries #17 & #22 (Fair Condition)
$14.00
BSC Mysteries - Choose One Book
$5.00
BSC #50 to 59 - Choose One Babysitters Club (Original Cover) Book
$8.00
Karen's Goldfish (Babysitters Club) Little Sister Book #16
$6.99
all Babysitters Collections
Birthday Cards
Birthday Card with Trading Card Pack (1992) Choose Yours
$10.00
Birthday Card Toy Story with Trading Card Pack (1995)
$15.00
Birthday Card Pinocchio with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992)
$10.00
Birthday Card Tinkerbell with (Trading Card Pack in Spanish)
$10.00
Birthday Card Cinderella with Trading Card Pack (1995)
$10.00
Birthday Card Disney Princess 12 Pages with Little Mermaid Trading Card Pack (1991)
$10.00
all Birthday Cards
Book Collections
Nancy Drew Books - Choose ONE
$10.00
Two of a Kind - Choose One Mary Kate & Ashley Book (1999)
$8.00
Boxcar Children (1989 Cover) #2 Surprise Island (Acceptable/Fair Copy)
$14.99
Man nennt mich Bummi German (1957 Hardcover) – by Martha Schlinker
$199.99
Two Mystery Harlequin Romance Novel Surprise Books
$10.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly Collection by Dorothy Haas - Choose ONE
$9.99
all Book Collections
Disney Collections
February 1994 Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Simpsons
$30.00
One Little Mermaid Sealed Trading Card Pack (1991)
$5.00
4 Pocahontas Card Packs (1993) 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift
$6.00
Beauty and the Beast Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 8 Cards) - 1992
$5.00
One Vintage Pack Donald Duck (6 Stickers inside)
$7.00
Hunchback's Clopin Figure and Trading Cards, 1996, 90s Disney Gifts, Hunchback of Notre Dame, Burger King Toys
$16.99
all Disney Collections
Fear Street/Pike/Cooney
Christopher Pike Assorted 90's Books: Choose One
$9.99
Halloween Night Set (Worn Copies) by R.L. Stine
$34.99
The Boyfriend RL Stine (1990 Version)
$16.99
Caroline Cooney Collection: Choose One Book
$14.99
Dead of Night: Haunted/The Halloween Party/The Sleepwalker (Fear Street Omnibus #3) Worn Copy (1994)
$79.99
Twisted RL Stine (Choose Your Cover)
$9.00
all Fear Street/Pike/Cooney
Game Collections
Pokemon Surprise Mini Bag, Nostalgia, Mystery bag, Stickers, Pikachu
$6.00
Super Mario MYSTERY Sweet Pouch (Party Favors, Gift Ideas, Retro Gifts, Nostalgia 90's)
$20.00
Pokémon Button, Sticker, Tattoo, Party Favors, Pikachu
$3.00
Beavis and Butthead 2 Pack Playing Cards (1996), MTV, Retro Gifts, 90s toys
$24.99
Pokemon VHS Sets, Pikachu Gifts, Vintage toys, Birthday Gift Ideas
$24.99
Pokémon Tattoos (1995), One Sealed Pack, Button and Bonus Tattoo, Party Favors, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Ideas
$5.00
all Game Collections
Goosebumps Collections
Goosebumps Sweet Pouch (Nostalgia Toys, Goosebumps, Retro Gifts, Party Favors, Bday Gifts)
$15.00
Tales to Give You Goosebumps Collection: Spooky Stories by R.L. Stine, Choose Your Book
$8.00
Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy)
$10.00
Ghosts of Fear Street Collection (Choose One Book) by R.L. Stine, 90's Editions
$8.00
Goosebumps TV Episode books, Original 90s Series R.L. Stine, Choose One Book
$9.00
Goosebumps #21-30 Classic Books by RL Stine, Choose One, Please READ description
$9.99
all Goosebumps Collections
Horror Collections
Chucky Mini Horror Nostalgia Bag, Trading Cards, Stickers
$9.99
Predator Treat Bag
$19.99
The Dollhouse That Time Forgot (Eerie, Indiana, No. 11) 1st Edition 1998 by Mike Ford
$39.99
Barbara Steiner Books - Choose One
$14.99
Diane Hoh Collection - Choose One Book (90's books)
$14.99
Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books)
$9.99
all Horror Collections
Lisa Frank & Candies
Fruit Chews Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Fruit Chew Flavors)
$4.50
Blue Razzle Dazzle Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Blue Raspberry Flavors)
$4.50
Fruit Medley Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Sour Candy Flavors)
$4.50
Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers
$3.00
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids
$5.00
Lisa Frank Keychains, Stocking Stuffers, Gift Ideas, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, Nostalgic Vibes, 90's Kids
$3.00
all Lisa Frank & Candies
Movie Collections
Horror buttons, 90s Style Pinback buttons, Halloween buttons, 90s gifts
$2.00
Charlie's Angels Natalie Doll (2000) Cameron Diaz
$45.00
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$7.50
Beetlejuice Mystery Pack, Mini Bag, Candy, Button, Trading Card Pack (1990), Halloween, 90's Gifts
$14.99
Batman Trading Packs, Choose One, Superheroes, 90's Kids, Nostalgic Gifts
$8.00
4 Flintstones Trading Card Packs 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift)
$15.00
all Movie Collections
Music Collections
NKOTB 90's Invite with Envelope (1990)
$4.99
NSYNC Surprise Pack (6 photos) 1999
$6.00
NKOTB Joey Mini Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts
$24.99
Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea)
$30.00
Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea)
$30.00
98 Degrees One Sealed Pack Music Photo Cards, Rare 1999, 90s Kids, Boy Bands, Nick Lachey
$10.00
all Music Collections
Sweet Valley Collections
Sweet Valley Jr. High: Choose One Book
$5.90
Aftershock/Earthquake - Choose One Sweet Valley High Book
$17.99
Sweet Valley Kids #21-40 - Choose ONE Circle Cover
$9.99
Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal
$15.00
Sweet Valley Confidential - Choose One by Francine Pascal
$10.00
Elizabeth's Valentine (1990 Blue Cover)
$12.99
all Sweet Valley Collections
Toy Collections
TY Beanie Babies 1999 Sealed, Choose ONE, International, Erin Britannia Glory Maple, Stocking Stuffers, 90's Gifts
$19.99
Peanut the Elephant Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack
$24.00
Mum the Bear (Beanie Baby 2001) Nostalgia Gifts, Retro Gifts, Valentine's Day Gift Bag, Beanie Baby
$20.00
Spooky Beanie Babies Trading Card Pack with 3 Cards
$7.99
Chip the Cat Teenie Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards
$14.99
Barbie 90's mini dream pack (Gifts for Kids, 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift)
$8.00
all Toy Collections
TV Show Collections
90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210
$2.00
90s style Combos - 5 Pinback buttons (Choose your OWN Random Mix of 5) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$7.50
90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons
$2.00
90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, 90s pins, Saved by the Bell
$2.00
Sabrina the Teenage Witch Mini Bundle, 90s fans, Vintage CDs
$19.99
Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack
$12.00
all TV Show Collections
VHS Collections
Fern Gully 2 Gift Set (VHS + 2 Sealed 1992 Packs)
$30.00
all VHS Collections
Unique Card Collections
The X Files Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards)
$6.99
Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$3.99
WCW (One 1991 Trading Card Pack) Each Pack has 12 Cards Inside, Jim Ross, Ric Flair, World Championship Wrestling
$5.00
Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs)
$9.99
Beanie Baby Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards)
$4.99
The X Files Card Mix (3 Packs)
$16.99
all Unique Card Collections
0 items in your cart
Close
Keep shopping! :)
Legal imprint
Close