Magic Unique Treasures

Magic Unique Treasures

Mystery Boxes

DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift NKOTB 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts $95.00
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan 80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan $95.00
Y2K Mystery Box, MTV, Sailor Moon, Buffy, Fear Street, Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, 90's fan, 90s gift Y2K Mystery Box, MTV, Sailor Moon, Buffy, Fear Street, Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, 90's fan, 90s gift $95.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift, Lisa Frank DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift, Lisa Frank $95.00
all Mystery Boxes

Buttons and Pins

90s style Pinback buttons (Choose One) 90s pins, 90s party favors 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose One) 90s pins, 90s party favors $2.75
90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $2.75
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $13.75
Lisa Frank Buttons (1.25 inch) Choose One Lisa Frank Buttons (1.25 inch) Choose One $2.75
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $2.75
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $2.75
all Buttons and Pins

Book Collections

American Girl Collection - Choose One Book American Girl Collection - Choose One Book $9.00
Boxcar Children- Choose a Title Boxcar Children- Choose a Title $7.00
Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose Your Title Nancy Drew Flashlight Books - Choose Your Title $8.00
Girl Talk Collection - Choose a Book by L.E. Blair Girl Talk Collection - Choose a Book by L.E. Blair $10.00
Nancy Drew Files Series 1986-1993 Covers (Worn Condition) Nancy Drew Files Series 1986-1993 Covers (Worn Condition) $9.99
Hardy Boys Series -Choose a Title Hardy Boys Series -Choose a Title $8.00
all Book Collections

Cartoon Collections

Archie Mystery Gift Pack Archie Mystery Gift Pack $14.99
Make Your Own Berenstain Bears Gift Bundle, Toy, Trading Cards, Coloring Book, Retro Gifts Make Your Own Berenstain Bears Gift Bundle, Toy, Trading Cards, Coloring Book, Retro Gifts $24.99
Berenstain Bears - One Sealed Trading Card Pack (1992) Berenstain Bears - One Sealed Trading Card Pack (1992) $5.00
Popeye (1994) Trading Card Sealed Pack (6 Cards per Pack) Popeye (1994) Trading Card Sealed Pack (6 Cards per Pack) $4.99
Dick Tracy ONE Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 8 Cards) - 1990 Dick Tracy ONE Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 8 Cards) - 1990 $5.00
Woody Woodpecker (DVD + 1997 Collector Tin) Woody Woodpecker (DVD + 1997 Collector Tin) $19.99
all Cartoon Collections

Disney Collections

Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) $6.00
Pocahontas Collections - Choose a Treasure Pocahontas Collections - Choose a Treasure $4.00
TinkerBell Trading Card One Pack (SPANISH) TinkerBell Trading Card One Pack (SPANISH) $8.00
Tarzan Collections - Choose a Treasure Tarzan Collections - Choose a Treasure $10.00
Birthday Card Sleeping Beauty with Sticker Pack (1998) Birthday Card Sleeping Beauty with Sticker Pack (1998) $10.00
Birthday Card Bambi with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) Birthday Card Bambi with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) $10.00
all Disney Collections

Horror Collections

Chucky One Sealed Pack, Fright Rags Chucky One Sealed Pack, Fright Rags $20.00
Sister Dearest 1991 edition by D.E. Athkins Sister Dearest 1991 edition by D.E. Athkins $14.99
Lois Duncan Thrillers (90's Covers) - Choose One Lois Duncan Thrillers (90's Covers) - Choose One $12.99
1988 Fright Flicks - One Wax Pack (1988) Choose Your Pack 1988 Fright Flicks - One Wax Pack (1988) Choose Your Pack $9.99
The Watcher by Lael Littke 1994 1st Edition - Like NEW! The Watcher by Lael Littke 1994 1st Edition - Like NEW! $34.99
Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) $9.99
all Horror Collections

Lisa Frank & Candies

Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers $3.75
Lisa Frank Fun Pack Lisa Frank Fun Pack $16.00
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids $5.00
Santa Around the World Trading Cards (1 Pack of 8 Cards), Stocking Stuffers, Family Traditions, Vintage Cards, Santa All Around the World Santa Around the World Trading Cards (1 Pack of 8 Cards), Stocking Stuffers, Family Traditions, Vintage Cards, Santa All Around the World $4.00
Lisa Frank Premade 90's Party favors, 90s Birthday Favors, 90s Party, Lisa Frank Party Lisa Frank Premade 90's Party favors, 90s Birthday Favors, 90s Party, Lisa Frank Party $25.00
Collectible Candy Tins filled with Candy! - Choose ONE Collectible Candy Tins filled with Candy! - Choose ONE $24.99
all Lisa Frank & Candies

Movie Collections

Jim Carrey Collections - Choose a Treasure Jim Carrey Collections - Choose a Treasure $6.00
Dark Crystal & Labyrinth Collections - Choose a Treasure Dark Crystal & Labyrinth Collections - Choose a Treasure $2.75
Free Willy 2 One Pack (1995) Free Willy 2 One Pack (1995) $4.00
Indiana Jones Chronicles Trading Card Pack Indiana Jones Chronicles Trading Card Pack $6.00
Addams Family One Pack (1991) Addams Family One Pack (1991) $5.00
FernGully Collections - Choose a Treasure FernGully Collections - Choose a Treasure $5.00
all Movie Collections

Music Collections

Spice Girls Mini Treasure Packs, Gum Pack Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack) 1997 Spice Girls Mini Treasure Packs, Gum Pack Stickers - (3 Bubble Gum Pieces plus Movie Sticker per Pack) 1997 $5.00
New Kids on the Block Keychains New Kids on the Block Keychains $3.50
Create your NKOTB Treat Bag, Gum Cassette, 90s Stocking Stuffer Nostalgic gift, 90's fan, Holiday Gift Ideas, New Kids on the Block Create your NKOTB Treat Bag, Gum Cassette, 90s Stocking Stuffer Nostalgic gift, 90's fan, Holiday Gift Ideas, New Kids on the Block $19.99
New Kids on the Block Mystery Pack New Kids on the Block Mystery Pack $30.00
Backstreet Boys DUO Sets - Choose one 90's Photo/Trading Card Combo (90's Gifts, BSB, Boy Bands, 90's Throwback) Backstreet Boys DUO Sets - Choose one 90's Photo/Trading Card Combo (90's Gifts, BSB, Boy Bands, 90's Throwback) $2.00
Michael Jackson Collections, Choose a Treasure Michael Jackson Collections, Choose a Treasure $2.75
all Music Collections

Sports Collections

Football NFL Collections - Choose a Treasure Football NFL Collections - Choose a Treasure $15.00
Wrestling Collections - Choose a Treasure Wrestling Collections - Choose a Treasure $2.75
Baseball Stickers 1995 Edition One Pack Baseball Stickers 1995 Edition One Pack $3.00
all Sports Collections

Toy Collections

Beanie Baby (1998) Inaugural Edition Trading Cards - Choose One #1 to 54 Beanie Baby (1998) Inaugural Edition Trading Cards - Choose One #1 to 54 $0.99
Chilly the Polar Bear Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack Chilly the Polar Bear Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack $19.99
Teddy Beanie Baby Mystery Treasure Bag, 90s nostalgia, trading card, Valentine's day gift Teddy Beanie Baby Mystery Treasure Bag, 90s nostalgia, trading card, Valentine's day gift $10.00
McDonalds Collectibles - Choose One McDonalds Collectibles - Choose One $5.00
Avon Robot Coin Piggy Bank Lost in Space (1985) Avon Robot Coin Piggy Bank Lost in Space (1985) $24.99
Stretch the Ostrich Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards Stretch the Ostrich Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards $14.99
all Toy Collections

TV Show Collections

Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack $12.00
Buffy Collections - Choose your Treasure Buffy Collections - Choose your Treasure $12.00
August 1995 Power Rangers 90's Treasure Bag (90s magazine, Trading Cards, Disney Gift Idea) August 1995 Power Rangers 90's Treasure Bag (90s magazine, Trading Cards, Disney Gift Idea) $30.00
Sailor Moon Collections - Choose a Treasure Sailor Moon Collections - Choose a Treasure $2.75
Rugrats Trading Cards (1997) One Sealed Pack, Nickelodeon, Stocking Stuffers, Party Favors Rugrats Trading Cards (1997) One Sealed Pack, Nickelodeon, Stocking Stuffers, Party Favors $8.00
Saved by the Bell 1992 Single Cards - Choose Your Card (#64-110) Saved by the Bell 1992 Single Cards - Choose Your Card (#64-110) $2.99
all TV Show Collections

Babysitters Collections

Goodbye-Stacey, Good-bye #13 - Choose One Babysitters Club Goodbye-Stacey, Good-bye #13 - Choose One Babysitters Club $6.99
BSC#40-49 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Collectors Cover BSC#40-49 - Choose ONE Babysitters Club Collectors Cover $5.98
Jessi's Secret Language #16 - Choose One Babysitters Club Jessi's Secret Language #16 - Choose One Babysitters Club $3.99
Claudia and the New Girl #12- Choose One Babysitters Club Claudia and the New Girl #12- Choose One Babysitters Club $3.99
Kristy's Great Idea #1 - Choose One Babysitters Club Kristy's Great Idea #1 - Choose One Babysitters Club $3.99
BSC Laminated Stoneybrook Map BSC Laminated Stoneybrook Map $14.99
all Babysitters Collections

Fear Street/Pike/Cooney

Trick or Treat (1989 Cover) by Richie Tankersley Cusick Trick or Treat (1989 Cover) by Richie Tankersley Cusick $16.99
Last Vampire Series - Choose One Christopher Pike Book Last Vampire Series - Choose One Christopher Pike Book $9.99
Missing (UK 1994 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine Missing (UK 1994 Edition) Fear Street Book by R.L. Stine $24.99
Party Summer - Fear Street (1995) UK - Worn Copy Party Summer - Fear Street (1995) UK - Worn Copy $39.00
Nightmare Room Collection - Choose One Book Nightmare Room Collection - Choose One Book $9.99
Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE Fear Street Slipcases (NO BOOKS) - Choose ONE $35.00
all Fear Street/Pike/Cooney

Goosebumps Collections

Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy) Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy) $10.00
Goosebumps Trading Cards (1 Pack) Choose Your Pack (Every pack comes with FREE GOOSEBUMPS STICKER) Goosebumps Trading Cards (1 Pack) Choose Your Pack (Every pack comes with FREE GOOSEBUMPS STICKER) $10.00
Let's Get Invisible! #6 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine Let's Get Invisible! #6 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine $9.99
Curse of the Mummy's Tomb #5 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine Curse of the Mummy's Tomb #5 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine $8.00
Say Cheese and Die! #4 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine Say Cheese and Die! #4 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine $8.00
Stay Out of the Basement #2 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine Stay Out of the Basement #2 Goosebumps (Choose a Cover) by R.L. Stine $8.00
all Goosebumps Collections

Sweet Valley Collections

Sweet Valley Kids Super Specials - Choose ONE Sweet Valley Kids Super Specials - Choose ONE $8.99
Sweet Valley High #21-29 - Choose a Cover Sweet Valley High #21-29 - Choose a Cover $5.99
Unicorn Club Series - Choose a Book by Francine Pascal Unicorn Club Series - Choose a Book by Francine Pascal $10.00
Sweet Valley High Twin Sister Doll Fashions Sweet Valley High Twin Sister Doll Fashions $125.00
Sweet Valley Super Editions - Choose a Cover Sweet Valley Super Editions - Choose a Cover $7.99
Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal $15.00
all Sweet Valley Collections

Unique Card Collections

Huntik Trading Cards One Pack Huntik Trading Cards One Pack $9.00
Iditarod Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards) Iditarod Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards) $5.00
Skeleton Warriors Premiere Edition Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 6 Cards) Skeleton Warriors Premiere Edition Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 6 Cards) $8.00
Desert Storm Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Desert Storm Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $4.00
Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $5.00
My Little Pony One (1986) Sticker Pack My Little Pony One (1986) Sticker Pack $5.00
all Unique Card Collections

Legal imprint