Magic Unique Treasures

Magic Unique Treasures

Mystery Boxes

80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan 80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan $95.00
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $85.00
DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $85.00
DESIGN your MINI 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your MINI 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $65.00
DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $85.00
NSYNC Care Package, Mystery Box, *NSYNC, Pop Music 90s box, 90s gift ideas, 90s gift box, Nostalgia, Justin Timberlake NSYNC Care Package, Mystery Box, *NSYNC, Pop Music 90s box, 90s gift ideas, 90s gift box, Nostalgia, Justin Timberlake $95.00
all Mystery Boxes

Back to the 80's

Dark Crystal 1982 Single Trading Cards - Choose ONE Dark Crystal 1982 Single Trading Cards - Choose ONE $2.00
E.T. Button & Mystery Card, 80s Party favors, Gift ideas, 80s pins E.T. Button & Mystery Card, 80s Party favors, Gift ideas, 80s pins $2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $2.00
80s Style Buttons, 80s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 80s gift ideas, 80s pins, Ninja Turtles 80s Style Buttons, 80s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 80s gift ideas, 80s pins, Ninja Turtles $2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $2.00
Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! Choose One 80s style pinback button, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s buttons! $2.00
all Back to the 80's

Back to the 60's & 70's

Grease Surprise 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978) Grease Surprise 6 Cards Treat Bag (1978) $5.99
Two Little Golden Books with Trading Cards Two Little Golden Books with Trading Cards $19.99
Beatles Treat Bag Covers Vary (One 1993 Trading Card Pack Inside) Beatles Treat Bag Covers Vary (One 1993 Trading Card Pack Inside) $9.99
Bob Marley One 1995 Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 6 Cards) Bob Marley One 1995 Trading Card Pack (Each Pack has 6 Cards) $5.00
Beatles - One Trading Card Pack of 9 Cards (1996) Beatles - One Trading Card Pack of 9 Cards (1996) $7.99
Bob Marley Gift Set, CD, Trading Cards 1995 Bob Marley Gift Set, CD, Trading Cards 1995 $20.00
all Back to the 60's & 70's

Babysitters Collections

Little Sister Book #66-74 - Choose One Babysitters Club Book By Ann M. Martin Little Sister Book #66-74 - Choose One Babysitters Club Book By Ann M. Martin $6.99
3 Book Set! (BSC Books 4 to 6) Babysitters Club 3 Book Set! (BSC Books 4 to 6) Babysitters Club $10.00
Baby-Sitters Club Halloween Mysteries #17 & #22 (Fair Condition) Baby-Sitters Club Halloween Mysteries #17 & #22 (Fair Condition) $14.00
BSC Mysteries - Choose One Book BSC Mysteries - Choose One Book $5.00
BSC #50 to 59 - Choose One Babysitters Club (Original Cover) Book BSC #50 to 59 - Choose One Babysitters Club (Original Cover) Book $8.00
Karen's Goldfish (Babysitters Club) Little Sister Book #16 Karen's Goldfish (Babysitters Club) Little Sister Book #16 $6.99
all Babysitters Collections

Birthday Cards

Birthday Card with Trading Card Pack (1992) Choose Yours Birthday Card with Trading Card Pack (1992) Choose Yours $10.00
Birthday Card Toy Story with Trading Card Pack (1995) Birthday Card Toy Story with Trading Card Pack (1995) $15.00
Birthday Card Pinocchio with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) Birthday Card Pinocchio with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) $10.00
Birthday Card Tinkerbell with (Trading Card Pack in Spanish) Birthday Card Tinkerbell with (Trading Card Pack in Spanish) $10.00
Birthday Card Cinderella with Trading Card Pack (1995) Birthday Card Cinderella with Trading Card Pack (1995) $10.00
Birthday Card Disney Princess 12 Pages with Little Mermaid Trading Card Pack (1991) Birthday Card Disney Princess 12 Pages with Little Mermaid Trading Card Pack (1991) $10.00
all Birthday Cards

Book Collections

Nancy Drew Books - Choose ONE Nancy Drew Books - Choose ONE $10.00
Two of a Kind - Choose One Mary Kate & Ashley Book (1999) Two of a Kind - Choose One Mary Kate & Ashley Book (1999) $8.00
Boxcar Children (1989 Cover) #2 Surprise Island (Acceptable/Fair Copy) Boxcar Children (1989 Cover) #2 Surprise Island (Acceptable/Fair Copy) $14.99
Man nennt mich Bummi German (1957 Hardcover) – by Martha Schlinker Man nennt mich Bummi German (1957 Hardcover) – by Martha Schlinker $199.99
Two Mystery Harlequin Romance Novel Surprise Books Two Mystery Harlequin Romance Novel Surprise Books $10.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly Collection by Dorothy Haas - Choose ONE Peanut Butter & Jelly Collection by Dorothy Haas - Choose ONE $9.99
all Book Collections

Disney Collections

February 1994 Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Simpsons February 1994 Disney adventure magazine, 90s nostalgia, Vintage, Birthday Gifts, Trading Card Pack, Simpsons $30.00
One Little Mermaid Sealed Trading Card Pack (1991) One Little Mermaid Sealed Trading Card Pack (1991) $5.00
4 Pocahontas Card Packs (1993) 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift 4 Pocahontas Card Packs (1993) 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift $6.00
Beauty and the Beast Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 8 Cards) - 1992 Beauty and the Beast Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 8 Cards) - 1992 $5.00
One Vintage Pack Donald Duck (6 Stickers inside) One Vintage Pack Donald Duck (6 Stickers inside) $7.00
Hunchback's Clopin Figure and Trading Cards, 1996, 90s Disney Gifts, Hunchback of Notre Dame, Burger King Toys Hunchback's Clopin Figure and Trading Cards, 1996, 90s Disney Gifts, Hunchback of Notre Dame, Burger King Toys $16.99
all Disney Collections

Fear Street/Pike/Cooney

Christopher Pike Assorted 90's Books: Choose One Christopher Pike Assorted 90's Books: Choose One $9.99
Halloween Night Set (Worn Copies) by R.L. Stine Halloween Night Set (Worn Copies) by R.L. Stine $34.99
The Boyfriend RL Stine (1990 Version) The Boyfriend RL Stine (1990 Version) $16.99
Caroline Cooney Collection: Choose One Book Caroline Cooney Collection: Choose One Book $14.99
Dead of Night: Haunted/The Halloween Party/The Sleepwalker (Fear Street Omnibus #3) Worn Copy (1994) Dead of Night: Haunted/The Halloween Party/The Sleepwalker (Fear Street Omnibus #3) Worn Copy (1994) $79.99
Twisted RL Stine (Choose Your Cover) Twisted RL Stine (Choose Your Cover) $9.00
all Fear Street/Pike/Cooney

Game Collections

Pokemon Surprise Mini Bag, Nostalgia, Mystery bag, Stickers, Pikachu Pokemon Surprise Mini Bag, Nostalgia, Mystery bag, Stickers, Pikachu $6.00
Super Mario MYSTERY Sweet Pouch (Party Favors, Gift Ideas, Retro Gifts, Nostalgia 90's) Super Mario MYSTERY Sweet Pouch (Party Favors, Gift Ideas, Retro Gifts, Nostalgia 90's) $20.00
Pokémon Button, Sticker, Tattoo, Party Favors, Pikachu Pokémon Button, Sticker, Tattoo, Party Favors, Pikachu $3.00
Beavis and Butthead 2 Pack Playing Cards (1996), MTV, Retro Gifts, 90s toys Beavis and Butthead 2 Pack Playing Cards (1996), MTV, Retro Gifts, 90s toys $24.99
Pokemon VHS Sets, Pikachu Gifts, Vintage toys, Birthday Gift Ideas Pokemon VHS Sets, Pikachu Gifts, Vintage toys, Birthday Gift Ideas $24.99
Pokémon Tattoos (1995), One Sealed Pack, Button and Bonus Tattoo, Party Favors, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Ideas Pokémon Tattoos (1995), One Sealed Pack, Button and Bonus Tattoo, Party Favors, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Ideas $5.00
all Game Collections

Goosebumps Collections

Goosebumps Sweet Pouch (Nostalgia Toys, Goosebumps, Retro Gifts, Party Favors, Bday Gifts) Goosebumps Sweet Pouch (Nostalgia Toys, Goosebumps, Retro Gifts, Party Favors, Bday Gifts) $15.00
Tales to Give You Goosebumps Collection: Spooky Stories by R.L. Stine, Choose Your Book Tales to Give You Goosebumps Collection: Spooky Stories by R.L. Stine, Choose Your Book $8.00
Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy) Horrors of the Haunted Museum - Goosebumps RL Stine (1994 copy) $10.00
Ghosts of Fear Street Collection (Choose One Book) by R.L. Stine, 90's Editions Ghosts of Fear Street Collection (Choose One Book) by R.L. Stine, 90's Editions $8.00
Goosebumps TV Episode books, Original 90s Series R.L. Stine, Choose One Book Goosebumps TV Episode books, Original 90s Series R.L. Stine, Choose One Book $9.00
Goosebumps #21-30 Classic Books by RL Stine, Choose One, Please READ description Goosebumps #21-30 Classic Books by RL Stine, Choose One, Please READ description $9.99
all Goosebumps Collections

Horror Collections

Chucky Mini Horror Nostalgia Bag, Trading Cards, Stickers Chucky Mini Horror Nostalgia Bag, Trading Cards, Stickers $9.99
Predator Treat Bag Predator Treat Bag $19.99
The Dollhouse That Time Forgot (Eerie, Indiana, No. 11) 1st Edition 1998 by Mike Ford The Dollhouse That Time Forgot (Eerie, Indiana, No. 11) 1st Edition 1998 by Mike Ford $39.99
Barbara Steiner Books - Choose One Barbara Steiner Books - Choose One $14.99
Diane Hoh Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) Diane Hoh Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) $14.99
Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) Richie Tankersley Cusick Collection - Choose One Book (90's books) $9.99
all Horror Collections

Lisa Frank & Candies

Fruit Chews Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Fruit Chew Flavors) Fruit Chews Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Fruit Chew Flavors) $4.50
Blue Razzle Dazzle Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Blue Raspberry Flavors) Blue Razzle Dazzle Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Blue Raspberry Flavors) $4.50
Fruit Medley Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Sour Candy Flavors) Fruit Medley Treat Bag (Sweet Treat, Goodie Bag, 90's Inspired, Candy Bag, Treat Bag, Birthday gift, Sour Candy Flavors) $4.50
Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers $3.00
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids $5.00
Lisa Frank Keychains, Stocking Stuffers, Gift Ideas, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, Nostalgic Vibes, 90's Kids Lisa Frank Keychains, Stocking Stuffers, Gift Ideas, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, Nostalgic Vibes, 90's Kids $3.00
all Lisa Frank & Candies

Movie Collections

Horror buttons, 90s Style Pinback buttons, Halloween buttons, 90s gifts Horror buttons, 90s Style Pinback buttons, Halloween buttons, 90s gifts $2.00
Charlie's Angels Natalie Doll (2000) Cameron Diaz Charlie's Angels Natalie Doll (2000) Cameron Diaz $45.00
90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Pinback buttons (5 pack), 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $7.50
Beetlejuice Mystery Pack, Mini Bag, Candy, Button, Trading Card Pack (1990), Halloween, 90's Gifts Beetlejuice Mystery Pack, Mini Bag, Candy, Button, Trading Card Pack (1990), Halloween, 90's Gifts $14.99
Batman Trading Packs, Choose One, Superheroes, 90's Kids, Nostalgic Gifts Batman Trading Packs, Choose One, Superheroes, 90's Kids, Nostalgic Gifts $8.00
4 Flintstones Trading Card Packs 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) 4 Flintstones Trading Card Packs 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) $15.00
all Movie Collections

Music Collections

NKOTB 90's Invite with Envelope (1990) NKOTB 90's Invite with Envelope (1990) $4.99
NSYNC Surprise Pack (6 photos) 1999 NSYNC Surprise Pack (6 photos) 1999 $6.00
NKOTB Joey Mini Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts NKOTB Joey Mini Pack, New Kids on the Block gift ideas, retro gifts $24.99
Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) $30.00
Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) Nsync 2K Treasure Bag (Disney magazine, Nostalgia Gift Idea) $30.00
98 Degrees One Sealed Pack Music Photo Cards, Rare 1999, 90s Kids, Boy Bands, Nick Lachey 98 Degrees One Sealed Pack Music Photo Cards, Rare 1999, 90s Kids, Boy Bands, Nick Lachey $10.00
all Music Collections

Sweet Valley Collections

Sweet Valley Jr. High: Choose One Book Sweet Valley Jr. High: Choose One Book $5.90
Aftershock/Earthquake - Choose One Sweet Valley High Book Aftershock/Earthquake - Choose One Sweet Valley High Book $17.99
Sweet Valley Kids #21-40 - Choose ONE Circle Cover Sweet Valley Kids #21-40 - Choose ONE Circle Cover $9.99
Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal Sweet Valley Hardcovers, Choose one Vintage Sweet Valley High book by Francine Pascal $15.00
Sweet Valley Confidential - Choose One by Francine Pascal Sweet Valley Confidential - Choose One by Francine Pascal $10.00
Elizabeth's Valentine (1990 Blue Cover) Elizabeth's Valentine (1990 Blue Cover) $12.99
all Sweet Valley Collections

Toy Collections

TY Beanie Babies 1999 Sealed, Choose ONE, International, Erin Britannia Glory Maple, Stocking Stuffers, 90's Gifts TY Beanie Babies 1999 Sealed, Choose ONE, International, Erin Britannia Glory Maple, Stocking Stuffers, 90's Gifts $19.99
Peanut the Elephant Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack Peanut the Elephant Beanie Baby (2000) with Trading Card & Sealed Pack $24.00
Mum the Bear (Beanie Baby 2001) Nostalgia Gifts, Retro Gifts, Valentine's Day Gift Bag, Beanie Baby Mum the Bear (Beanie Baby 2001) Nostalgia Gifts, Retro Gifts, Valentine's Day Gift Bag, Beanie Baby $20.00
Spooky Beanie Babies Trading Card Pack with 3 Cards Spooky Beanie Babies Trading Card Pack with 3 Cards $7.99
Chip the Cat Teenie Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards Chip the Cat Teenie Beanie Baby (1999) Sealed with Trading Cards $14.99
Barbie 90's mini dream pack (Gifts for Kids, 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) Barbie 90's mini dream pack (Gifts for Kids, 90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) $8.00
all Toy Collections

TV Show Collections

90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 $2.00
90s style Combos - 5 Pinback buttons (Choose your OWN Random Mix of 5) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Combos - 5 Pinback buttons (Choose your OWN Random Mix of 5) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $7.50
90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $2.00
90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, 90s pins, Saved by the Bell 90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, 90s pins, Saved by the Bell $2.00
Sabrina the Teenage Witch Mini Bundle, 90s fans, Vintage CDs Sabrina the Teenage Witch Mini Bundle, 90s fans, Vintage CDs $19.99
Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack $12.00
all TV Show Collections

VHS Collections

Fern Gully 2 Gift Set (VHS + 2 Sealed 1992 Packs) Fern Gully 2 Gift Set (VHS + 2 Sealed 1992 Packs) $30.00
all VHS Collections

Unique Card Collections

The X Files Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards) The X Files Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 9 Cards) $6.99
Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Equestrian Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $3.99
WCW (One 1991 Trading Card Pack) Each Pack has 12 Cards Inside, Jim Ross, Ric Flair, World Championship Wrestling WCW (One 1991 Trading Card Pack) Each Pack has 12 Cards Inside, Jim Ross, Ric Flair, World Championship Wrestling $5.00
Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) $9.99
Beanie Baby Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) Beanie Baby Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 10 Cards) $4.99
The X Files Card Mix (3 Packs) The X Files Card Mix (3 Packs) $16.99
all Unique Card Collections

Legal imprint