Magic Unique Treasures

Magic Unique Treasures

80s Section

80s style Pinback buttons, Choose Buttons, 80s Party, 80s Party Favors, 80s Button 80s style Pinback buttons, Choose Buttons, 80s Party, 80s Party Favors, 80s Button $2.75
She-Ra Hardcover Book 1985 · Princess of Power · The Spirit of She-Ra She-Ra Hardcover Book 1985 · Princess of Power · The Spirit of She-Ra $14.95
Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts Design Your 80's Trends Mystery Box! 80's Kids, 80s Birthday Gifts, Retro Gifts, 80s Gift, Christmas Gifts $95.00
Rainbow Brite (1993) One Sticker Pack Rainbow Brite (1993) One Sticker Pack $4.95
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan 80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan $95.00
80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan 80's Trends Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 80's fan $95.00
all 80s Section

Barbie

Barbie Gift Box, Birthday Gift IDEAs, Barbie Gift Box, Birthday Gift IDEAs, $24.95
Millennium Princess Barbie (sealed toy) 1999 Mattel Millennium Princess Barbie (sealed toy) 1999 Mattel $16.95
Barbie Toys 1992 Collection (Cake Topper, Birthday Gift) Barbie Toys 1992 Collection (Cake Topper, Birthday Gift) $16.95
Super Gymnast Barbie 1999 Toy (Cake Topper, Birthday Gift) Super Gymnast Barbie 1999 Toy (Cake Topper, Birthday Gift) $16.95
Barbie & Friends 1994 Toy Collection - Choose a Toy, Gift, (Cake Topper Idea) Barbie & Friends 1994 Toy Collection - Choose a Toy, Gift, (Cake Topper Idea) $14.95
Barbie 1984 Fashion Cards (1990/91) 4 by 5 inch Barbie 1984 Fashion Cards (1990/91) 4 by 5 inch $3.95
all Barbie

Books

Baby-Sitters Club Complete Guide (Book) Baby-Sitters Club Complete Guide (Book) $25.00
Display Babysitter's Club BOOK Boxes! No Books Display Babysitter's Club BOOK Boxes! No Books $15.00
Baby-Sitters Club Trivia and Puzzle Fun Book (1992) Baby-Sitters Club Trivia and Puzzle Fun Book (1992) $24.99
Princess Dear Diary Handheld - Tiger Electronics (1999) Sealed BLUE, Nostalgia Toys Princess Dear Diary Handheld - Tiger Electronics (1999) Sealed BLUE, Nostalgia Toys $125.00
Mallory on Strike Preowned Puzzle - Babysitters Club Mallory on Strike Preowned Puzzle - Babysitters Club $125.00
Mary Kate & Ashley Collectibles - You Pick! Mary Kate & Ashley Collectibles - You Pick! $2.75
all Books

Buffy

Buffy - Women of Sunnydale Trading Pack Buffy - Women of Sunnydale Trading Pack $9.95
Buffy Photo Pack Buffy Photo Pack $9.95
Buffy Mystery Treasure Box! Vintage gifts, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Idea Buffy Mystery Treasure Box! Vintage gifts, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Idea $95.00
Buffy Playing Card Collector's Deck Buffy Playing Card Collector's Deck $14.95
Buffy Mystery Treasure Box! Vintage gifts, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Idea Buffy Mystery Treasure Box! Vintage gifts, Retro Gifts, Birthday Gift Idea $95.00
Buffy Collectible Card Game - Choose Hero or Villan Buffy Collectible Card Game - Choose Hero or Villan $24.95
all Buffy

Buttons

90's Buttons - Pick Your Favorites (1.25 inch) Party Favors, 90s Gifts 90's Buttons - Pick Your Favorites (1.25 inch) Party Favors, 90s Gifts $2.75
80's Buttons - Pick Your Favorites (1.25 inch) Party Favors, 80s Shows 80's Buttons - Pick Your Favorites (1.25 inch) Party Favors, 80s Shows $2.75
90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 90s Style Buttons, 90s Party favors, Choose One Pinback button, 90s gift ideas, y2k, 90s pins, 90210 $2.75
90210 Pins, Choose a Button/Card (1991) 90210 Pins, Choose a Button/Card (1991) $2.75
90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons 90s style Choose Your Pinback buttons (Choose Your Faves) 90s pins, 90s party, Pinback Buttons $2.75
80s style (5 pack) pinback buttons, Mystery Scoop, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s Buttons 80s style (5 pack) pinback buttons, Mystery Scoop, 80s pins, 80s Party, 80s Buttons $9.95
all Buttons

Digital Instant Download

Halloween Collage 90s Party | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | Halloween Collage 90s Party | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
Year 1983 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 40th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | Year 1983 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 40th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
PRINTABLE Collage Instant Download | Britney Spears | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | PRINTABLE Collage Instant Download | Britney Spears | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
Year 1993 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 30th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | Year 1993 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 30th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
Year 2000 Fun Fact | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | y2k Party | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | Year 2000 Fun Fact | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | y2k Party | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
Year 1973 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 50th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | Year 1973 Fun Fact Sheet | PRINTABLE Sheet Instant Download | 50th Birthday | Anniversary | Reunion | PRINTABLE | Party Decorations | $1.99
all Digital Instant Download

Disney

Lion King Collectibles - Choose a Treasure Lion King Collectibles - Choose a Treasure $5.95
TinkerBell Trading Card One Pack (SPANISH) TinkerBell Trading Card One Pack (SPANISH) $5.00
Tarzan 1999 Disney Adventures Magazine Tarzan 1999 Disney Adventures Magazine $19.95
Birthday Card Toy Story with Trading Card Pack (1995) Birthday Card Toy Story with Trading Card Pack (1995) $20.00
Birthday Card Pinocchio with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) Birthday Card Pinocchio with Disney Trading Card Pack (1992) $10.00
Birthday Card Tinkerbell with (Trading Card Pack in Spanish) Birthday Card Tinkerbell with (Trading Card Pack in Spanish) $10.00
all Disney

Disney Magazines

Weird Al Yankovic April 1991 Disney Adventures Magazine Weird Al Yankovic April 1991 Disney Adventures Magazine $24.95
Power Rangers 1994 Disney Adventure Magazine Power Rangers 1994 Disney Adventure Magazine $29.95
Disney Adventures 2004 Magazine, Raven, SpongeBob, Simpsons, Kim Possible Disney Adventures 2004 Magazine, Raven, SpongeBob, Simpsons, Kim Possible $19.95
Fresh Prince 1992 3D Disney Adventures Magazine w. 3d Glasses Fresh Prince 1992 3D Disney Adventures Magazine w. 3d Glasses $29.95
Home Improvement 1993 Disney Adventure Magazine Home Improvement 1993 Disney Adventure Magazine $19.95
Jammin Justin 2004 Disney Adventures Magazine, Super Mario, Harry Potter, Friends, Simpsons, Finding Nemo Jammin Justin 2004 Disney Adventures Magazine, Super Mario, Harry Potter, Friends, Simpsons, Finding Nemo $19.95
all Disney Magazines

Goosebumps

Goosebumps Trading cards (1 pack), Goosebumps collectibles Goosebumps Trading cards (1 pack), Goosebumps collectibles $7.95
Goosebumps 90's Bookmarks - Choose One Goosebumps 90's Bookmarks - Choose One $19.95
Goosebumps Softcover Books - Choose Your Own Book: Monster Blood, Night of the Living Dummy, The Blob, Say Cheese and Die Goosebumps Softcover Books - Choose Your Own Book: Monster Blood, Night of the Living Dummy, The Blob, Say Cheese and Die $9.95
Goosebumps Spooky Pack, Vintage Gifts, Retro Gifts, R.L. Stine Goosebumps Spooky Pack, Vintage Gifts, Retro Gifts, R.L. Stine $24.95
Goosebumps VHS Tapes - Choose a Tape Goosebumps VHS Tapes - Choose a Tape $20.00
Ghost Next Door Goosebumps DVD/Book Set Ghost Next Door Goosebumps DVD/Book Set $19.99
all Goosebumps

Halloween Treasures

90s/80s Halloween Pin pack 15 Button Pack, 90s or 80s Halloween Party 90s/80s Halloween Pin pack 15 Button Pack, 90s or 80s Halloween Party $39.95
Halloween Theme Mystery 90's Trends Box Halloween Theme Mystery 90's Trends Box $95.00
Halloween Night Omnibus Book (1994) Halloween Night Omnibus Book (1994) $39.95
Spooky Mystery Pack, Goosebumps books, 90s gifts, Casper, Spooky Pack, Spooky Mystery Pack, Goosebumps books, 90s gifts, Casper, Spooky Pack, $34.99
Beetlejuice One Pack (1990) Beetlejuice One Pack (1990) $7.95
McDonalds Collectibles - Choose One McDonalds Collectibles - Choose One $5.95
all Halloween Treasures

Horror & Fear Street

Goodnight Kiss Collection - Choose a book by R.L. Stine Goodnight Kiss Collection - Choose a book by R.L. Stine $15.00
Nightmare Hall Collection - Choose One Book (1993-1995 Covers) Nightmare Hall Collection - Choose One Book (1993-1995 Covers) $10.00
Fear Street Extra Inserts (Authentic) 90's - Choose Your Insert Fear Street Extra Inserts (Authentic) 90's - Choose Your Insert $20.00
Autographed Sweet Dreams by Kate Daniel (1992 1st Edition) Autographed Sweet Dreams by Kate Daniel (1992 1st Edition) $50.00
Fear Street Hardcovers Ex-Library Editions - Choose Yours Fear Street Hardcovers Ex-Library Editions - Choose Yours $25.00
Cheerleader Series: Choose a Fear Street Book Cheerleader Series: Choose a Fear Street Book $10.00
all Horror & Fear Street

Lisa Frank & Small Gifts

Lisa Frank Inspired Gift Bundle Lisa Frank Inspired Gift Bundle $29.95
Archie Mystery Gift Pack Archie Mystery Gift Pack $24.99
Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers Lisa Frank Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids, Stocking Stuffers $5.95
Unicorn or LF Sticker - 90's LF Inspired - Choose a Sticker Unicorn or LF Sticker - 90's LF Inspired - Choose a Sticker $2.50
Beanie Baby Puzzle Card - Choose One (1998), Stocking Stuffers, Trading Cards Beanie Baby Puzzle Card - Choose One (1998), Stocking Stuffers, Trading Cards $2.95
Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids Lisa Frank Wristlet Keychains, 90's Inspired, Choose One, Party Favors, Stocking Stuffers, Nostalgic Gifts, 90's Gift Ideas, 90's Kids $6.95
all Lisa Frank & Small Gifts

Music

BSB Song/CD Cards (Choose a Backstreet Boys Trading Card) BSB Song/CD Cards (Choose a Backstreet Boys Trading Card) $5.75
Pop Superstars Photos Rare 1998 Italy, Choose a Photo Nirvana, Spice Girls, All Saints, Jon Bon Jovi, Five, Hanson, Aqua, Madonna Pop Superstars Photos Rare 1998 Italy, Choose a Photo Nirvana, Spice Girls, All Saints, Jon Bon Jovi, Five, Hanson, Aqua, Madonna $4.95
Backstreet Boys - One Sealed pack of 6 Photo Cards (1997) Backstreet Boys - One Sealed pack of 6 Photo Cards (1997) $3.00
Music Mania Paperback book Rare Edition 2000 Music Mania Paperback book Rare Edition 2000 $29.95
90's Mystery MUSIC themed trends Box! NSYNC, Britney Spears, BSB, Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, 90's fan, Boy Bands 90's Mystery MUSIC themed trends Box! NSYNC, Britney Spears, BSB, Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, 90's fan, Boy Bands $95.00
Cher CD & TV Guide Collector Set Cher CD & TV Guide Collector Set $24.99
all Music

Mystery Boxes

DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift DESIGN your 90's Y2K Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, Birthday boxes, Mystery box, 90's fan, Vintage toys, Retro 90s gift $95.00
Pets Themed 90s Mystery Box Medium Themed Personalized, Cats, Dogs, 90s Trends, Pet Mystery Box, 101 Dalmations, Scooby Doo Pets Themed 90s Mystery Box Medium Themed Personalized, Cats, Dogs, 90s Trends, Pet Mystery Box, 101 Dalmations, Scooby Doo $95.00
Spice Girls Mystery Box! Spice Girls Mystery Box! $125.00
90's Trends Mini Pink y2k Mystery Box 90's Trends Mini Pink y2k Mystery Box $65.00
TGIF Nights MYSTERY Nostalgia Box! TGIF Nights MYSTERY Nostalgia Box! $95.00
90s Trends Mystery Box Themed Personalized 90s Trends Mystery Box Themed Personalized $95.00
all Mystery Boxes

New Kids on the Block

NKOTB One Pack (Series 2) New Kids on The Block Trading Pack NKOTB One Pack (Series 2) New Kids on The Block Trading Pack $5.95
New Kids Mini Bubble Gum Cassettes - Choose New Kids Mini Bubble Gum Cassettes - Choose $7.95
New Kids - Mystery Pack New Kids on the Block New Kids - Mystery Pack New Kids on the Block $39.95
NKOTB Mini Treat Bag NKOTB Mini Treat Bag $19.99
New Kids Button - Choose New Kids on the Block Pin New Kids Button - Choose New Kids on the Block Pin $3.25
New Kids Earrings - Choose Pair - New Kids on the Block New Kids Earrings - Choose Pair - New Kids on the Block $16.95
all New Kids on the Block

NSYNC

NSYNC Bobblehead Dolls Collectible 2001 Nostalgia, Justin Timberlake NSYNC Bobblehead Dolls Collectible 2001 Nostalgia, Justin Timberlake $29.95
NSYNC Single Card Hologram, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake, Choose a Card NSYNC Single Card Hologram, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake, Choose a Card $4.95
NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake $24.95
NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake $24.95
NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake $24.95
NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake NSYNC 6 Trading Card Set, Stocking Stuffers, NSYNC, Justin Timberlake $24.95
all NSYNC

Rugrats Magazines

Rugrats Canada Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia Rugrats Canada Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia $39.95
Rugrats Texas USA Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia Rugrats Texas USA Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia $39.95
Rugrats Madagascar Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue Rugrats Madagascar Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue $39.95
Rugrats Indonesia Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue Rugrats Indonesia Magazine, Nickelodeon 2002 Issue $39.95
Rugrats Sweden Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Norway, Denmark Rugrats Sweden Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Norway, Denmark $39.95
Rugrats Greenland Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia Rugrats Greenland Nickelodeon 2002 Issue, Nostalgia $39.95
all Rugrats Magazines

Spice Girls

Spice Girls VHS Tapes - Pick a Tape Spice Girls VHS Tapes - Pick a Tape $19.95
Spice Girls Autograph Book with Pen (Sealed) 1997 Spice Girls Autograph Book with Pen (Sealed) 1997 $59.95
Spice Girls (3 Gum Pieces) Spice Girls (3 Gum Pieces) $5.95
Spice Girls Mystery Pack Spice Girls Mystery Pack $59.95
Spice Girls 4x6 Photos - Choose a Photo (1997) Spice Girls 4x6 Photos - Choose a Photo (1997) $4.95
Spice Girls 4x6 Photos - Choose a Photo (1997) Spice Girls 4x6 Photos - Choose a Photo (1997) $4.95
all Spice Girls

Trading Card Packs

Charlie & the Chocolate Factory Mini Movie Card Pack Charlie & the Chocolate Factory Mini Movie Card Pack $2.00
Flintstones Pack (Fred & Wilma) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) Flintstones Pack (Fred & Wilma) 1993 (90's favorites, vintage toys, birthday gift) $3.00
Rare Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack Rare Sailor Moon Trading Card Pack $14.95
Star Trek 25th Anniversary Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) Star Trek 25th Anniversary Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) $5.00
Star Trek 25th Anniversary Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) Star Trek 25th Anniversary Trading Card Pack (1 Pack of 12 Cards) $4.99
Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) Marilyn Monroe (2 Sealed Packs) $9.99
all Trading Card Packs

TV Shows & Movies

Power Rangers Collections, Choose a Collectible Power Rangers Collections, Choose a Collectible $6.00
90210 Fans -Choose a Treasure 90210 Fans -Choose a Treasure $2.75
Seinfeld DVD & TV Guide Collector Set Seinfeld DVD & TV Guide Collector Set $24.99
Pirates of the Caribbean Trio Gift Set, Disney adventure magazine, Early 2000's, Birthday Gift Ideas Pirates of the Caribbean Trio Gift Set, Disney adventure magazine, Early 2000's, Birthday Gift Ideas $34.99
Premade 90s Box, Personalized Gift, NSYNC, Leo, 70s Show, September 3rd US Bowling Day Holiday Premade 90s Box, Personalized Gift, NSYNC, Leo, 70s Show, September 3rd US Bowling Day Holiday $69.95
All My Children Collector Gift Set All My Children Collector Gift Set $29.99
all TV Shows & Movies

Legal imprint