Babysitters Club Stacey's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, BSC theme, Mystery box, 90's fan, 90's Books


Need a fun gift idea to give or a fun gift for yourself to enjoy? 💜 Introducing our Babysitters Club box featuring Stacey. We've curated items inside that are items Stacey would have loved to have received in her own mystery box!

Items included in this box are:

Two Stacey books from the 90's (not the new editions currently in circulation). Books will be either Stacey mystery, portrait or a book from the regular series.

One authentic 90's Stacey bookmark

One authentic 90's BSC trading card featuring a Stacey book

Stacey is the club's treasurer and also great in math! We've included a 1989 edition of Sideways Arithmetic from Wayside School by Louis Sachar which include 50 mindboggling math puzzles for you to solve!

Stacey is originally from New York. We've included a sealed pack of Home Alone 2 Lost in New York trading card pack.

Stacey plays Mrs. Darling from Peter Pan in Starring the Babysitters Club Super Special, we've included a Diamond Edition of Peter Pan on DVD.

When Stacey was 5 years old, she was on Cinderella's float in the Macy's parade. We've included a sealed pack of Cinderella trading cards with your box.

Stacey likes to doodle on the cover of her notebook. We've included your very own mini Etch a Sketch inside your box.

We all know Stacey loves fashion! We've included some fun stickers for you to enjoy.

Stacey has a pig collection in her room and can even do Porky Pig's voice! We've included an authentic Squealer beanie baby trading card in a protective case for you to start your own collection.

In Mary Anne Saves the Day, Mary Anne says Stacey dresses like a model. We've included a fun Disney vintage toy camera inside the box.

Stacey loves the movie Mary Poppins, we've included Mary Poppins book and cassette tape from 1977.

Stacey and Mallory walk to school together sometimes. They would use a secret code in the morning. White means let's walk together and red towel means she has to walk her siblings to school. We've enclosed Secret Messages Teresa toy barbie figure which comes with a pencil and a small locker.

Stacey loves tennis. We've included a Tennis toy made by Digi sportz.

Stacey loves films, movies and Broadway. We've included a CD with the songs from the greatest shows in town performed by The Stage Door Orchestra. Song titles are from Grease, My fair Lady, Cabaret, West Side Story and more!

When Stacey is old enough to drive, she wants to save up money to get a red convertible. We've included a cute Hello Kitty toy in a red convertible.

If Stacey could be any animal, she would be a lion or a panther. We've included an adorable Lion beanie baby named Bushy inside your box.

To check out all types of different 90's boxes we make, drop by our shop and take a peek by clicking here:

If you have an idea or inspiration for a certain 80's or 90's box you have in mind, send us a message and we can let you know if we can create it or simply choose one of our design your own boxes we offer and enter your favorites! We also have premade ones you can also choose from that we post from time to time.

More items premiering soon, so check back often!

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-2 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept cancellations

Legal imprint