Babysitters Club Mary Anne's Mystery Box! Nostalgic gift, BSC theme, Mystery box, 90's fan, 90's Books


Need a fun gift idea to give or a fun gift for yourself to enjoy? 💜 Introducing our Babysitters Club box featuring Mary Anne. We've curated items inside that are items Mary Anne would have loved to have received in her own mystery box!

Items included in this box are:

Two Mary Anne books from the 90's (not the new editions currently in circulation). Books will be either Mary Anne mystery, portrait or a book from the regular series.

One authentic 90's Mary Anne bookmark

One authentic 90's BSC trading card featuring a Mary Anne book

One of Mary Anne's all-time favorite movies was Sixteen Candles, we've included a DVD of the movie.

Mary Anne loves Wizard of Oz. We've included a sealed trading card pack with really fun cards from the movie inside!

Mary Anne loves cats. We've included a cat beanie baby named Chip the cat in the box.

Mary Anne got her kitten Tigger in Book #10 Logan Likes Mary Anne. We've included a Tigger toy keychain from Winnie the Pooh. =-)

Mary Anne loves Chocolate Chips and winter. We've included some chocolate Sno Caps for you to enjoy!

Rock music is Mary Anne's favorite. We've included a sealed 90's pack of Rock Music cards.

In the book The Fire at Mary Anne's House, Mary Anne says she's been writing in journals ever since she could write. We've included an empty journal and a blue pen for you to start your journal like Mary Anne!

Mary Anne is woken up at night by her cat, Tigger and she smells the smoke in the book The Fire at Mary Anne's House. We've included fire and writing in this vintage toy "Write and Sniff" a Wendy's kids meal toy from the 90's. Pen with ink that smells like smoke. Toy is still sealed.

In honor of the book Mary Anne and the Zoo Mystery, we've included a sealed pack of San Diego Zoo cards.

In Mary Anne's Makeover (book#60) Mary Ann mentions when she was eight she wanted to be a fairy princess. We've included a 90's Barbie princess figure.

Since Mary Anne is the secretary and keeps track of time and records, we've included a Little Stars (Sanrio) toy watch in the box.

Mary Anne's room is decorated with framed pictures of Alice in Wonderland. We've included a 1991 original Little Golden book version of Alice in Wonderland.

In Kristy's Great Idea, Mary Anne says she's been to New York City twice before and in Dawn and Too Many Sitters she said she once had the complete set of Boxcar Children. We've combined these two fun facts and added the Boxcar Super Special The Mystery in New York inside the box.

To check out all types of different 90's boxes we make, drop by our shop and take a peek by clicking here:

If you have an idea or inspiration for a certain 80's or 90's box you have in mind, send us a message and we can let you know if we can create it or simply choose one of our design your own boxes we offer and enter your favorites! We also have premade ones you can also choose from that we post from time to time.

More items premiering soon, so check back often!

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-2 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept cancellations

Request a cancellation within: 0 hours of purchase

I don't accept returns or exchanges

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

Legal imprint